A range of payback schemes are in place around the country
Related stories
The government has been urged to overhaul community sentences in England and Wales to place the emphasis on intensive physical labour.
A survey by right-leaning think tank Policy Exchange found that 60% of 2,000 people polled thought the sentences were “soft” or “weak”.
The think tank said community sentences were flawed and should be replaced by more punitive “work orders”.
The Ministry of Justice said proposals would be published soon.
The Policy Exchange said in a report that the community payback scheme – the toughest type of order – often involved charity shop work and serving tea at luncheon clubs.
Report author Robert Kaye called for community sentences to be focused on punishment and to be “radically reformed to improve compliance and reduce reoffending”.
He said: “Evidence shows that orders with a clear punishment element have lower reoffending rates.”
Under his recommendations, offenders would be required to do hard, physical work that benefited the public such as cleaning off graffiti and building social housing.
And some offenders would be tagged and have to work five days a week, with benefits withdrawn if they did not comply.
His report comes ahead of a government announcement on plans for changes to rehabilitation which could see less jail time and more community orders for offenders.
Victims’ commissioner Louise Casey questioned whether making tea or costumes for the Notting Hill Carnival was sufficient punishment.
She said community sentences should be tough, intensive and visible to communities affected by the offenders’ actions.
“It’s as if the legal principle of punishment in sentencing is somehow unseemly – rather than a legitimate and correct response to those who step outside society’s agreed rules,” she said.
“To have the confidence of those who pass sentence, the public and of victims in particular, this must change.”
A Ministry of Justice spokesman said: “We are looking at how private and voluntary sector providers can be involved in running community sentences to make them more rigorous, ensure proper compliance, and deliver better value for the taxpayer.”
YouGov polled more than 2,000 adults online for the Policy Exchange survey.
This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Gabe Watson pleaded guilty last year to the manslaughter of his wife
Related stories
An American man known as the “honeymoon killer” has been deported from Australia and is heading for the US.
Gabe Watson, 33, was jailed in Australia for the manslaughter of his wife while scuba diving during their honeymoon on the Great Barrier Reef.
Australian officials said Watson had left on a flight accompanied by police.
The Australian government had been awaiting a guarantee from the US that he would not face the death penalty if he were re-tried at home in Alabama.
Australia’s Immigration Minister Chris Bowen told local media that the assurance had been received from the US.
Watson left the country at about noon local time on Thursday accompanied by immigration officials and police officers, Mr Bowen said.
Watson is thought likely to face murder charges in Alabama.
After his wife’s death in 2003, Watson was initially charged with murder in Queensland.
It was alleged he turned off his new bride’s air supply during a diving trip and held her underwater.
He pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of manslaughter in 2009 and completed an 18-month term in prison earlier this month.
This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

No offer was made for the apartments at the auction
An apartment block due to be sold at auction in Ballybofey, Donegal, on Wednesday, was withdrawn when it failed to attract a single serious bid.
Attempts to sell the 47-apartment building took place amid a protest by contractors who were owed money.
The apartments at Navenny Place, Trusk Road, were to be sold as a package with a guide price of 550,000 euro.
Their reserve price meant the dwellings would be valued at just under 11,700 euro each.
A shouted bid of 5,000 euro from the crowd was promptly dismissed by the auctioneer.
Disgrunted builders and sub-contractors staged a protest as potential buyers arrived at the unfinished site.
The one, two and three bedroom apartments had been placed in receivership and range in size from 63 square metres to 108 square metres.
The properties were marketed as “completed to at least first fix stage” and were being sold in one single lot “as is” at current stage of construction.
There are more than 2,800 so-called ghost estates in the Republic according to a survey carried out by the Irish government.
This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Protesters are staging a fees demonstration in London
Lines of police are holding back thousands of student protesters in central London, in a wave of protests against higher tuition fees and university budget cuts.
A police van, marooned in the protest on Whitehall, has been vandalised.
Students are staging occupations at universities including Royal Holloway, Plymouth, Birmingham, London South Bank, UCL and UWE Bristol.
Police have warned they will make arrests if protests become violent.
Marches, walkouts and protest events are also taking place at universities and colleges in Manchester, Liverpool, Sheffield, Bristol, Southampton, Oxford, Cambridge, Leeds, Newcastle, Bournemouth, Cardiff, Glasgow and Edinburgh.
School pupils have walked out of lessons in Winchester, Cambridge, Leeds and London.
Speaking ahead of the protests, Liberal Democrat leader Nick Clegg called on students to reconsider the coalition’s tuition fees plans before they take part in a day of protests.
“Examine our proposals before taking to the streets. Listen and look before you march and shout,” said Mr Clegg.
Students are protesting against plans to increase tuition fees in England to £9,000 per year and to withdraw public funding for university teaching budgets for many subjects.
Students in London have been walking out to join a demonstration
A student march two weeks ago ended in an attack on the Conservatives’ headquarters building – which has since been followed by 65 arrests.
The Metropolitan Police have warned they will not tolerate criminal activity, violence or disorder.
Protesters in London are planning to demonstrate outside the headquarters of the Liberal Democrat party, whose leaders have become a particular target for student protests.
Students have accused Liberal Democrat MPs of planning to break their pledge to vote against raising fees.
The demonstrations are not being organised by the National Union of Students – and there are uncertainties about the pattern of protests.
A “carnival of resistance” has been promised, with music and speeches.
Students at the University of Birmingham are staging a protest over tuition fees and budget cuts.
Mark Bergfeld, spokesman for the Education Activist Network, one of the groups organising the protests, said: “We have the right to protest, we have the right to civil disobedience, we have the right to occupy our lecture halls.”
And an anarchist group has also called for “roaming marches” to “disrupt business” across central London, rather than a static stand-off with police.
Protest leaders have claimed that an “unprecedented wave of student revolt is unfolding” – and they say they are following in the spirit of student protests of 1968.
Dominic Casciani, BBC News, central London
As some of the protesters began gathering outside the University of London Union, the atmosphere was fairly lively, with the students banging pots and drums and cowbells. One of the chants against Nick Clegg went “shame on you for turning blue” – and there are others that are unrepeatable, but the mood was jovial.
Some students are protesting against the removal of the education maintenance allowance for further education students and sixth formers on low incomes. Others are holding placards campaigning more generally about the rise in tuition fees – some from the Socialist Worker student society, some from the Education Activists Network.
One woman is holding a home-made placard calling for “rich parents for all”. There are significant numbers of police but they are standing well back and appear relaxed.
As well as the planned rise in tuition fees, students are also campaigning about wider budget cuts for higher education.
Further education students and sixth-formers are also protesting at plans to remove the education maintenance allowance, which gives low-income students up to £30 a week to help with the costs of staying in full-time education.
The fees protest held two weeks ago in Westminster was attended by an estimated 50,000 students – and ended with a breakaway group forcing their way into the Millbank office complex.
There had only been a thin line of police guarding the Millbank building – but the police have made clear that they will be better prepared for Wednesday’s protests.
“The Met has long respected and protected the right to protest and we will continue to do so, but anyone who plans to take to the streets of London intent on disorder, violence and crime should understand that it won’t be tolerated and they will be arrested,” said Commander Bob Broadhurst.
Send your pictures and videos to [email protected] or text them to 61124 (UK) or +44 7725 100 100 (International). If you have a large file you can upload here.
Read the terms and conditions
This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.
