High Street justice

Adrian GoldbergBy Adrian Goldberg

B&Q storePaul Findlay was accused of defrauding a B&Q store in North Shields
Related stories

“Basically it’s threatening people and bullying them for a ridiculous amount of money. If they had a case to fight why haven’t they taken me to court?”

Paul Findlay went into the B&Q store in North Shields last May to buy a cable for the new HDTV he had bought to watch the FA Cup Final later that day.

As he was leaving the store with his purchase, security guards stopped him and accused him of purposefully putting a more expensive cable into a box with a cheaper price.

Mr Findlay says he was looking at cables, but distracted by his children running around, he put the wrong cable in the box.

He was accused by staff of purposefully putting a cable worth £19.98 into a box with a tag of £18.16 – a difference of £1.82.

Speaking to the 5 live Investigates programme, he said: “It was an honest mistake. If I didn’t have my kids there it wouldn’t have happened, I was just flustered.

“I had been at work the night before, I wanted to get back to watch the match.”

The police were called to the store, and Mr Findlay was arrested and immediately bailed.

However, after watching CCTV footage and considering Mr Findlay’s explanation, they told him they would take no further action. It seemed that he was vindicated.

Demand for damages

Two days after the incident, Mr Findlay received a letter from a company called Retail Loss Prevention (RLP).

“Many thieves are not prosecuted in the criminal courts. Retailers are increasingly having to take responsibility themselves to redress this balance”

Jackie Lambert MD, Retail Loss Prevention

Acting on behalf of B&Q, RLP demanded £137.50 in damages to cover the cost of dealing with the incident – such as staff costs and administration.

RLP works for a number of major High Street chains, pursuing so-called civil recovery claims against those accused of theft from shops. Such claims are often pursued without the involvement of the police or criminal courts.

Citizens Advice estimates that about 600,000 civil recovery letters have been sent out over the last decade.

The introduction of civil recovery was not based on any new law. Instead, companies such as RLP have made use of existing civil law. Its dramatic growth has so far received little public attention.

According to letters seen by the 5 live Investigates programme, RLP usually demands £87.50 for items allegedly stolen worth less than £10 and £137.50 for items worth between £10 and £100.

Citizens Advice believes thousands of people who are accused of stealing petty amounts are being charged unreasonable sums for shops’ losses.

Richard Dunstan, social policy adviser for Citizens Advice, says thin many cases it seems there was an honest mistake on the part of the alleged shoplifter.

reenactment of shoplifter stealingThe British Retail Consortium estimates retailers lose over £1 billion each year to shoplifters

B&Q declined to comment on Mr Findlay’s case. However, Jackie Lambert, RLP’s managing director, defends the practice.

The civil recovery market is unregulated but Ms Lambert says agencies follow clear guidelines to ensure civil recovery is open, fair and transparent.

She says the work of companies such as RLP has become necessary.

“Many thieves are not prosecuted in the criminal courts,” she said.

“Retailers are increasingly having to take responsibility themselves to redress this balance.”

This view is echoed by the British Retail Consortium (BRC). Tom Ironside, of the BRC, told the BBC: “At a time when police resources are being cut, it’s vital retailers are able to take this action as retail crime costs £ 1.1 billion per year.”

Heavy handed

Richard Dunstan, of Citizens Advice, says: “We don’t dispute that shoplifting is a serious problem and we are not condoning it but recovering costs do not justify any means.”

“It would be wholly inappropriate if individuals were being brow beaten into an admission of guilt”

Assistant Chief Constable Allyn Thomas ACPO

Citizens Advice says civil recovery letters are threatening court action and unpaid damages are being pursued by debt collection agencies, even though there may have been no criminal charge.

Furthermore, the details of the accused may be entered on a national database of individuals involved in civil recovery incidents. Such records can be accessed by retailers and prospective employers.

John, from south-west London, was incensed when his two sons received letters from RLP demanding damages to cover the cost of investigating the alleged offence of changing labels on wallets in a High Street shop – an accusation John’s sons deny.

But John was most worried about the threat in the letters he received that his sons’ names would appear on the national database of civil recovery wrongdoers.

“I thought that might harm their future life chances,” he said. “They were going to be on this blacklist for five years.”

Jackie Lambert, of RLP, says: “The primary purpose of civil recovery is to deter future incidents of crime. Indeed, it is a proven deterrent with less than 3% of wrongdoers being involved in future incidents.”

LISTEN TO THE FULL REPORT

Hear more on 5 live Investigates on Sunday, 9 January at 2100hrs on BBC Radio 5 live

Download the 5 live Investigates podcast Post comments on our Facebook page Tweet the 5 live Investigates team

Ms Lambert says the work of civil recovery agencies complements that of the police.

However, the police have concerns over the way civil recovery companies sometimes operate.

Assistant Chief Constable Allyn Thomas, of the Association of Chief Police Officers (ACPO), says: “Some retailers feel frustrated by the courts and the police who see shoplifting at the lower end of offending, and we support their efforts to remedy that, but the problem comes when some companies respond disproportionately.

“It would be wholly inappropriate if individuals were being brow beaten into an admission of guilt.”

ACC Thomas says anyone subjected to continued and inappropriate approaches from civil recovery organisations should report the matter to the police.

The Law Commission is due to launch a consultation this spring on unfair consumer practices. Civil recovery will be included in their inquiry and this could lead to a recommendation for future legislation.

You can hear the full report on 5 live Investigates on Sunday, 9 January at 2100 GMT on BBC Radio 5 live.

You can also listen again on the BBC iPlayer or by downloading the 5 live Investigates podcast.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Newspaper review

Sunday newspapers

The gun attack in Arizona which left six people dead and a US congresswoman critically injured makes several of Sunday’s front pages.

The Mail on Sunday speculates that the attack on Gabrielle Giffords might be “linked to her support for abortion”.

The Sunday Telegraph says she is “a gun-owner and supporter of the right to bear arms”.

But despite this, the broadsheet says she had been named as a “political campaign target for conservatives” by former Alaska governor Sarah Palin.

It’s bonus time for Britain’s bankers and few papers are happy about it.

The Sunday Times says the public will also be angry they are rewarding themselves “while the economic mess they created is still playing itself out”.

“The issue of bankers’ pay has become highly toxic at Westminster,” says the Observer.

But Fraser Nelson, in the News of the World, dares to suggest that the cash-strapped government should welcome the bonuses because of the tax that will be paid on them.

The Independent on Sunday devotes its front page to marking the first anniversary of the Haiti earthquake in which 230,000 people died.

Despite billions of pounds in aid, it says the “squalid, dangerous” conditions in which survivors still live are “a festering global scandal”.

“All this in a country which, staggeringly, hosts tourists from cruise ships,” the paper goes on.

“It can supply pina coladas, but not hope to its own people.”

The much-anticipated sacking of Liverpool manager Roy Hodgson dominates Sunday’s back pages.

The Sunday Mirror says Anfield favourite Kenny Dalglish – chosen as caretaker – is on an SOS mission.

But the Sunday Express warns that the enormity of the task in hand “could tarnish his glorious reputation” with Liverpool fans.

“Kenny goes from a pleasure-boat passenger to captain of the Titanic”, writes the Sunday People.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Fresh deadly unrest hits Tunisia

Protesters in in the Tunisian capital, TunisThere has been sporadic unrest over economic hardship since last month in Tunisia
Related stories

At least one person has been killed in fresh unrest over unemployment in Tunisia, eyewitnesses say.

One hospital source told Reuters news agency that one person had been shot dead during a demonstration in the western town of Thala.

AFP news agency, quoting witnesses as saying police had fired on protesters, put the death toll at four.

There has been no comment from Tunisian officials. The protests erupted last month over a lack of freedom and jobs.

A hospital source Thala, about located about 200 km (125 miles) southwest of the capital Tunis, that several people had been admitted to the hospital after the latest clashes. “At least one was killed,” he said.

On Friday, the US expressed concern over the government’s handling of the demonstrations.

State department spokesman PJ Crowley said the Tunisian government was asked to respect people’s right to assemble peacefully.

The demonstrations began after a man set fire to himself on 17 December in the central Sidi Bouzid region to protest against the police confiscating fruit and vegetables that he was selling without a permit.

He died on Tuesday, while another man is reported to have electrocuted himself as part of the protests.

Demonstrations are rare in Tunisia, where there are tight controls aimed at preventing dissent. The unrest has been linked to frustrations with the president and the ruling elite.

There have been similar protests in over jobs and food in neighbouring Algeria.

Two people have been killed and hundreds wounded during riots in several Algerian regions in recent days.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Kate in black at friend’s wedding

Kate MiddletonWilliam and Kate revealed more details of their own wedding plans this week

The nation is eager to see her big white dress, but Kate Middleton chose a little black one for a friend’s wedding this weekend.

Prince William, 28, and his future bride attended the wedding of Harry Aubrey-Fletcher and Louise Stourton in Boroughbridge, West Yorkshire.

Miss Middleton – who turns 29 on Sunday – wore a black velvet coat, black dress and black pill box hat.

The royal couple will tie the knot themselves on 29 April.

The Mail on Sunday reported that Prince Harry and Princess Beatrice were also among the guests at the wedding.

The royal bride-to-be was accompanied by a number of security personnel, it added.

The groom was reportedly one of William’s oldest friends and a fellow pupil at Eton school.

More details of William and Kate’s wedding day plans were recently released by St James’s Palace.

The service will begin at 1100 BST at Westminster Abbey and they will be married by the Archbishop of Canterbury.

Miss Middleton will travel to the abbey in a car – rather than a glass coach – but afterwards, the newly-weds will return to Buckingham Palace in a formal carriage procession.

A large reception will take place in the afternoon and in the evening there will be a smaller, private dinner followed by dancing.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Guatemala bus accident kills 14

People stand around a bus after it plunged into a ravine near San Marcos in western GuatemalaSurvivors said the brakes on the bus failed
Related stories

A bus crash in Guatemala’s western highlands has killed at least 14 people and injured at least 25 others.

The victims were all ex-paramilitaries who had been working for a government reforestation project.

They were travelling to collect their pay in the town of Concepcion Tutuapa, 280km west of Guatemala City, when the bus left the road and plunged into a 50m (164ft) deep ravine.

Traffic accidents are frequent on Guatemala’s mountain roads.

“The driver was going very fast and when we got to the curve his brakes failed and we went into the ravine,” one survivor of the accident told local media.

There were about 60 passengers on the bus, all of them former members of the paramilitary civil patrols set up by the military to combat left-wing rebels during Guatemala’s 1960-1996 internal conflict.

Hundreds of thousands of Guatemalans from rural communities were forced to join the civil patrols, and veterans have since campaigned to receive payment for their service.

The reforestation project the victims of the accident were working on was part of a government programme to create employment for ex-paramilitaries.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Retail boss in inflation warning

generic picture of shoppers in fashion storeMr McGeogh said the VAT increase was set to be overshadowed by other cost pressures
Related stories

One of Scotland’s leading fashion retailers has warned a “tidal wave of inflation” is about to break over the clothing sector.

Iain McGeogh, majority shareholder of the M&Co chain of shops, said the start of this year was looking “very tough”.

He blamed rising cost pressures and the increase in VAT from 17.5% to 20%.

Mr McGeogh said the increase in tax from 4 January was set to be overshadowed by other pressures, from cotton prices to freight costs.

He also told BBC Radio Scotland’s Business Scotland programme it was “a terrible mistake” to allow people to stay on in jobs after the age of 65.

He claimed workers from that age could be less productive and make it more difficult for younger people to find jobs and develop their careers through management.

Mr McGeogh, who has long kept a very low profile, has built up Mackays into one of Scotland’s largest private companies.

“We’ve got cotton price increases, acrylic price increases, labour increases in producer countries, freight costs have doubled. So at the end of the day, VAT is not really a major issue”

Iain McGeogh M&Co majority shareholder

A pawnbroker from the 1830s, it has been in family hands since 1961, since when it has built up a strong position in value fashion retail.

He bought out his brother’s share and, in 2006, changed the name to M&Co.

Headquartered at Inchinnan in Renfrewshire, the chain now includes 300 stores throughout Britain, employing more than 3,000 people, typically in market town shopping streets.

With its online business, it claims to have 11 million customers. Its most recent accounts, for the year to last February, showed revenue rising to £182m, with pre-tax profits up sharply to £10.4m.

The company is now developing a franchise operation in China.

Discussing the year ahead, Mr McGeogh said: “I think there’s going to be a tidal wave of inflation coming through. Next [a rival fashion chain] have been talking about 7% or 8% prices increases, and that is happening. There will be more increases after that.

“We’ve got cotton price increases, acrylic price increases, labour increases in producer countries, freight costs have doubled. So at the end of the day, VAT is not really a major issue.”

Mr McGeogh said the inflation in garment manufacturing was largely explained by extensive factory closures in China, as workers shifted to more lucrative electronics work.

In the radio programme, Mr McGeogh also criticised recent moves allowing people to choose to stay at work after 65, even if their employers would prefer them to retire.

He said the change was “a terrible mistake”.

He continued: “I happen to be 65, so I can say it. I’m not planning to retire, I have no problem with anybody who is fit and able and full of energy working on, but I have a problem with those whose ability is diminishing and speed of execution is slowing up, saying ‘I want to stay on’, and having full employment rights.

“Where do you get the young people coming into the system? Where does the management progress through?”

Iain McGeogh’s comments can be heard on BBC Radio Scotland’s Business Scotland programme at 1005 GMT on Sunday. They can be heard again on the iPlayer for a week, or downloaded as a podcast.

The programme includes discussions with Caroline Donaldson, of Kynesis business consultancy, Frank Blin, senior partner at PricewaterhouseCoopers, and Martin Togneri, formerly head of Scottish Development International.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Voodoo and raucous rhythms

A year ago, a powerful earthquake brought death and destruction to poverty-stricken Caribbean country of Haiti, killing 230,000 people and leaving 1.5 million homeless.

Twelve months on, Mike Thomson from BBC Radio 4’s Today programme returned there to meet a voodoo artist using the bones of earthquake victims in his work. But first, he witnessed the spectacle of a ‘rara’ street band winding its way through the streets of Port au Prince.

To see the enhanced content on this page, you need to have JavaScript enabled and Adobe Flash installed.

WARNING: This slideshow contains images of human bones.

Photography and audio by Mike Thomson. Slideshow production by Paul Kerley. Publication date 9 January 2011.

More audio slideshows from BBC Radio 4:

The funeral photographer

Saving the Spitfire

The Archers at 60

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Computers for all?

XO-1.75 laptopThe OLPC project hopes to release a dedicated tablet computer by 2012
Related stories

Everybody is trying to grab a piece of the tablet action at the gadget geekfest known as the Consumer Electronics Show.

Among them, the One Laptop Per Child (OLPC) project, whose mission is to bring low-powered, low-cost devices to the developing world.

They have just launched a hybrid computer that turns into a tablet, but plan to release a dedicated device by 2012.

The new $165 (about £106) XO-1.75 laptop will start shipping after the summer to countries around the world to bring school children into the computer age.

Its precursor cost around $199 (about £128) and OLPC says around two million have now been distributed.

The big challenge with the new laptop was to reduce power consumption.

OLPC chief technology officer Ed McNierney told BBC News they have slashed the wattage from five watts to two by using low powered ARM-based chips from Marvell technology.

“When I ask, ‘How long do you think your battery has to last when you have no place to plug it in?’ we know that is a big problem to solve,” he said.

“With this new design we can get between seven to eight hours of battery life. When we move to a tablet it will be 10 to 12 hours.”

The XO-1.75’s motherboard, which holds the chips and other components, sits behind the laptop screen, making it easy to twist around and use as a tablet device.

The other half of the laptop houses the keyboard and battery.

Even though OLPC did not have a tablet to show off like the scores of other companies here at the show, Mr McNierney talked about the focus that will drive the design.

“One of the major issues we have to deal with is making it unbreakable”

Ed McNierney Chief technology officer, OLPC

“A lot of tablets are designed for entertainment and consumption, but that is not what we do,” he said.

“We really think the tablet needs to be a fully-functioning educational experience that is designed for creating, sharing, editing, enjoying and collaborating with other children and teachers.”

The XO-3 tablet will have a screen the same size as Apple’s popular iPad at 9.7in (25cm).

The particular market OLPC caters for has, in part, led to the tablet being delayed until next year.

“One of the major issues we have to deal with is making it unbreakable,” Mr McNierney said. “Not many people would give their iPad to a six-year-old child and even fewer would give their iPad to a child that lives in the desert.

“We need to have unbreakable display screens, long life components and a system that can be sealed with no openings to let in dust, sand and water.”

The device will also include a cover to protect the screen and a solar panel to help solve power issues.

Chip-maker Marvell has sponsored OLPC’s tablet project to the tune of $5.5m (£3.5m).

The firm’s chips and processors will power a number of tablets including that of OLPC.

But what will really make this device compelling is the price – $100.

“The overall price is going to get competitive for all tablets as prices keep coming down,” said Weili Dai, co-founder of Marvell.

XO-1.75 laptopsThe laptops have to be robust and cheap to produce

OLPC’s Mr McNierney said the drive to cheaper components is largely down to Apple and the success it has had with its iPad. To date, over 7.5 million have been sold, accounting for nearly half of all tablet sales last year.

“I think they have re-ignited the market in a way that is going to create huge volumes for the components we use.

“One of the most important pieces in our current laptop designs and tablet designs is the NAND storage and solid state components. Prices on those systems have dropped dramatically because everyone is buying them.

“The same is true for touch screens. We didn’t think we could afford those [but] the prices have dropped by about 50% in the last year and it is that volume across the industry that is great for us.”

Ms Dai said she thought that as prices continued to come down, tablets would become more ubiquitous.

“What I see is one step further as these type of devices are used everywhere. I use the term ‘smart furnishing’.

“We will need a different type of tablet for different applications, such as our home lighting systems, security systems, home appliances and entertainment systems,” added Ms Dai.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Jo murder left ‘hole of despair’

The Yeates family, with Jo Yeates second right, on her 18th birthdayChris Yeates, second left, pictured with Jo and his parents, said she was a “personal inspiration”

The brother of murdered landscape architect Jo Yeates has told how her death has created a “surreal hole of despair” in his life.

Chris Yeates described his sister as a “personal inspiration” and said he was confident police would find her killer.

The 28-year-old said: “All my memories of Jo are positive and I’ve etched these into my mind.”

The body of Miss Yeates, 25, was found in a lane near Bristol on Christmas Day, a week after she disappeared.

Post-mortem tests revealed she had been strangled.

Mr Yeates said the discovery of his younger sister’s body had given him “an acceptance of the situation” but not closure.

In a statement, he said: “I got to say a final emotional goodbye to Jo and the despair I had was replaced with a wave of deep sadness.

“The last couple of weeks I have been spending time with my partner and her son, comforting each other and trying to get our heads around what has happened whilst supporting my parents as much as possible.

“The tremendous amount of support we have had from family, friends and the general public has been truly overwhelming and brings a sense of slight elation at an otherwise tragic time.”

His partner Alla Ritch described Miss Yeates as a “perfect beacon of light and a great example to us all to live every day to our fullest potential”.

She added: “It seems that only the darkest of all souls could literally put her bright light out like this.

Jo Yeates and Greg Reardon

Miss Yeates was reported missing on 19 December and found dead on Christmas Day

Timeline: Jo Yeates murder

“Nothing in the world is going to change what happened to Jo, but I hope that whoever is responsible will be stopped from doing any more harm to innocent people.”

Miss Yeates was last seen alive on 17 December. She spent the evening in the Bristol Ram pub with colleagues before visiting a supermarket to buy a pizza on her way home to the Clifton area of Bristol.

Her boyfriend Greg Reardon reported her missing on 19 December after he returned from a weekend away.

Her snow-covered body was found in Longwood Lane, Failand, by dog walkers.

On Saturday, Miss Yeates’ parents, David and Theresa Yeates, from Ampfield, near Romsey in Hampshire, said their lives had been “changed for ever” the day she disappeared.

A book of condolence has been opened at Christ Church Clifton, close to the flat in Canynge Road that Miss Yeates shared with Mr Reardon.

On Saturday afternoon, players from Bristol City Football Club warmed up ahead of their match with Sheffield Wednesday wearing shirts showing Miss Yeates’ picture and a police contact number.

A £10,000 reward has been offered through Crimestoppers for information leading to a conviction and The Sun newspaper has added its own £50,000 reward.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

New law will keep the Queen’s head on stamps

StampsThe government confirmed last year that Royal Mail would be sold off
Related stories

A law is set to be passed guaranteeing that UK stamps will continue to feature the Queen’s head – even if Royal Mail enters foreign hands.

At present, there is no legal obligation to show the monarch’s image, although Royal Mail has always done so.

Postal Affairs Minister Ed Davey said any potential buyer would have to be “mad” to drop it, but the new law would provide a “safeguard” just in case.

German and Dutch operators are expected to be leading bidders in the sell-off.

Mr Davey held talks with Buckingham Palace after learning that draft legislation, paving the way for a sell-off, would give the Queen a veto over any use of her image but would not insist her head be shown.

Now it has emerged that amendments to the Postal Services Bill will be put forward next week to close that potential loophole.

Mr Davey told the Mail on Sunday: “After listening to views of members of both Houses of Parliament and the palace, we have agreed this additional safeguard.”

The newspaper had previously claimed there was “anger” at the Palace over the situation, but Mr Davey said his department and royal officials had “worked extremely well together to prepare for this initiative”.

Labour had accused the government of being deliberately vague in the draft legislation, suggesting that “the fewer strings they attach, the more money they will get from a foreign buyer”.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.