Pass paragraph to another page JavaScript/HTML

I know there are similar questions about it but I’ve stumbled on different problem. I have a lots of paragraphs in my page and I want to add “favorite” buttons to every single one of them. So far I’ve attached “favorite” button to one of them and passed it to another page. One more thing… I want to add those favorited paragraphs like a list. Simply I want to make FAVORITES page. This is my first page:

<form action="pages/login_screen.html">
    <p id="first">A<span id="heart"><i class="fa fa-heart-o" aria-hidden="true"></i></span></p>
    <script>
            $(window).on('load',function(){
              if(localStorage.toggled != "with_toggle"){
                $("#heart").html('<i class="fa fa-heart" aria-hidden="true"></i>');
              }else{
                $("#heart").html('<i class="fa fa-heart-o" aria-hidden="true"></i>');
              }
            });
            $('#heart').toggleClass(localStorage.toggled);
            $('#heart').on('click',function(){
              if (localStorage.toggled != "with_toggle") {
                $("#heart").html('<i class="fa fa-heart-o" aria-hidden="true"></i>');
                $('#heart').toggleClass("with_toggle", true);
                localStorage.toggled = "with_toggle";
                localStorage.removeItem("paragraphValue");
              } else {
                $("#heart").html('<i class="fa fa-heart" aria-hidden="true"></i>');
                $('#heart').toggleClass("with_toggle", false);
                localStorage.toggled = "";
                var paragraph = document.getElementById("first").innerHTML;
                localStorage.setItem("paragraphValue", paragraph);
                return false;
              }
            });
    </script>
    <button><a href="pages/login_screen.html">GO</a></button>
    <p>B</p>
    <p>C</p>
    <p>D</p>
    <p>E</p>
    <p>F</p>
    <p>G</p>
</form>

And this is my second Page:

<span id="favorites"><!--FAVORITES HERE--></span>
<script>
    document.getElementById("favorites").innerHTML = localStorage.getItem("paragraphValue");
</script>