Tomlinson post-mortem report held

Ian Tomlinson filmed as he was apparently pushed to the groundNewspaper seller Ian Tomlinson was not involved in the G20 protests

A post-mortem examination report into the death of a man at the G20 protests last year has been withheld from authorities, it has emerged.

It was carried out by a forensic pathologist on behalf of the policeman who pushed Ian Tomlinson.

The report was withheld from the Crown Prosecution Service, Independent Police Complaints Commission and the coroner.

The coroner said he had “doubts” about it being withheld and would pursue the matter.

The officer’s lawyers cited legal privilege in withholding it.

Mr Tomlinson died after he was pushed at the protests in April last year.

Related stories

He had been on his way home from work and was not involved in the demonstrations.

Pc Simon Harwood, a member of Scotland Yard’s territorial support group, was filmed striking the 47-year-old newspaper seller with his baton and pushing him to the ground in the City of London.

No criminal proceedings were brought over Mr Tomlinson’s death because experts could not agree on how Mr Tomlinson had died.

In July, Director of Public Prosecutions Keir Starmer said there was a “sharp disagreement between the medical experts” about the cause of death.

Pathologist Freddy Patel, who has since been suspended from the medical register over three other cases, concluded that Mr Tomlinson died of natural causes.

However, two other experts said he died from internal bleeding after falling to the ground.

Another pathologist, Ben Swift, jointly conducted the third post-mortem examination on behalf of Pc Harwood.

‘Defence’ material

On Tuesday, the coroner revealed that the officer’s lawyers had refused to disclose Dr Swift’s findings, citing legal privilege.

The coroner said he had “doubts” about that and would “pursue” it.

The Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC), which investigated the case, and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), which decided not to bring charges, have now confirmed that they have not seen Dr Swift’s report either.

The CPS said the report was “defence” material and it was not entitled to see it.

Last week, Dr Patel was suspended for three months by the General Medical Council.

It found that his fitness to practise was “impaired” because of the way he dealt with three other cases.

He had been already barred from carrying out Home Office forensic pathology work.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Church defiant over Koran burning

Terry JonesTerry Jones said he had prayed over the matter but insisted the Koran-burning would go ahead

A small US church says it will defy international condemnation and go ahead with plans to burn copies of the Koran on the 9/11 anniversary.

The top US commander in Afghanistan warned troops’ lives would be in danger if the Dove World Outreach Center in Florida went through with the stunt.

Muslim countries, the US government and Nato have also hit out at the plan.

But organiser, Pastor Terry Jones said: “We must send a clear message to the radical element of Islam.”

Analysis

The Dove World Outreach Center may only represent a handful of people, but its incendiary plans haven’t emerged out of nowhere.

The role of Islam in America has become a hot button issue with social and political implications.

While most Americans would probably take issue with exhortations to burn the Koran, there is clearly widespread concern about the influence of Islam.

Protests over the planned location of an Islamic centre close to Ground Zero in New York, and similar controversy in Murfreesboro, Tennessee have highlighted popular anxiety about Islam in America.

Earlier this year, an opinion poll found that 53% of Americans view Islam unfavourably, with only 42% viewing the religion favourably.

Reports about young American Muslims being radicalised on the internet have helped to stoke fears about the nature of a religion indelibly associated, since 9/11, with a violent assault on the US.

Far from subsiding over time, anxiety seems to have deepened. As a result, American Muslims say they feel more isolated than at any time since the 2001 attacks.

The controversy comes at a time when the US relationship with Islam is very much under scrutiny.

There is heated debate in the country over a proposal to build a mosque and Islamic cultural centre streets from Ground Zero, site of the 9/11 attacks, in New York.

‘Significant problems’

Despite having a congregation of just 50, the plans of the church in Gainesville have gained worldwide notoriety, sparking demonstrations in Afghanistan and Indonesia.

Gen David Petraeus, the top US commander in Afghanistan, said on Monday that the action could cause problems “not just in Kabul, but everywhere in the world”.

“It is precisely the kind of action the Taliban uses and could cause significant problems,” he said in a statement.

The Vatican, the Obama administration and Nato have also expressed concern over the plan.

White House spokesman Robert Gibbs said on Tuesday that “any type of activity like that that puts our troops in harm’s way would be a concern”.

Afghan protesters in Kabul on 6 September 2010Protesters burned an effigy of Pastor Terry Jones

Nato chief Anders Fogh Rasmussen blasted the plans, telling reporters that burning Korans violated the Nato alliance’s “values”.

Dr Jones – author of a book entitled Islam is of the Devil – has said he understands the general’s concerns but that it was “time for America to quit apologizing for our actions and bowing to kings”.

Another pastor at the church told the BBC that members intended to burn several hundred copies of the holy book on Saturday evening, the ninth anniversary of the 9/11 attacks, in defiance of an order by the city not to hold an open air bonfire.

Muslims consider the Koran to be the word of God and insist it be treated with the utmost respect. Any intentional damage or show of disrespect to the holy book is deeply offensive to them.

An interfaith group of evangelical, Roman Catholic, Jewish, and Muslim leaders meeting in Washington on Tuesday condemned the proposals as a violation of American values and the Bible.

News of the bonfire has also sparked protests in Afghanistan and Indonesia.

In Kabul on Monday, about 500 protesters chanted “long live Islam” and “death to America” as they set fire to an effigy of Mr Jones.

Thousands of mostly Muslim demonstrators rallied around Indonesia at the weekend.

Story retracted

Claims that US soldiers have desecrated the Koran in both Afghanistan and Iraq have caused bloodshed in the past.

There were deadly protests in Afghanistan in 2008, when it emerged that a US soldier deployed to Iraq riddled a copy of the holy book with bullets.

And further lives were lost in Afghan riots in 2005 when Newsweek magazine printed a story alleging that US interrogators at Guantanamo Bay had flushed a copy of the Koran down a toilet.

The story later turned out to be false and was retracted by the magazine.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Powerful tremor rattles NZ city

Damaged buildings in Christchurch. 7 Sept 2010Christchurch faces a massive rebuilding programme after the earthquake

The New Zealand city of Christchurch has suffered its most damaging aftershock since a powerful earthquake at the weekend.

The 5.1 magnitude tremor cut power, further damaged buildings and sent frightened residents running into the streets, national media reported.

Regular aftershocks have hit the area since Saturday’s 7.1 quake.

Related stories

However, Wednesday’s was the most damaging so far because it was at a shallow depth, experts said.

A state of emergency is still in force in Christchurch, with schools remaining closed.

City Mayor Bob Parker has appealed for calm and urged residents to avoid travelling.

He said the intensity of the latest tremor reduced many emergency workers to tears.

“It was a devastatingly, vicious sharp blow to the city,” he told NewstalkZB.

“This was a terrifying moment. We have just had to evacuate our Civil Defence headquarters. We have got staff in tears, we have got fire engines going through the middle of the city, power is out and a lot of people are very, very churned up by that.”

A reporter for New Zealand’s TV One station described Wednesday’s aftershock as “sharp and very sudden”.

Roger Sutton, chief executive of power company Orion, told the station that “quite a lot of power” had been lost as a result but he anticipated having systems up again quickly.

Christchurch City Council spokeswoman Diane Keenan described it as “a really big, stiff jolt”.

“It was vertical rather than side to side like the first one. If you were in a car the road moved up and down,” she said.

It was centred 10km south-east of Christchurch at a depth of 6km, the GeoNet agency reported.

New Zealand’s ministry of civil defence has warned that an aftershock of up to 6.0 magnitude is possible in the next few days.

Saturday’s earthquake caused widespread structural damage, but there were no fatalities.

Some of Christchurch’s most historic buildings have been damaged beyond repair and are to be pulled down.

More than 100 aftershocks have rocked the area since Saturday.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Digital subjects ‘priority’ call

GoogleThe report wants to help nurture the next generation of digital industries

Creative digital technologies must be a “national priority” in UK universities, says an industry and university report.

The UK should be trying to nurture ideas for online businesses like Facebook and Google, says the Council for Industry and Higher Education.

The promotion of so-called Stem subjects, including science and maths, should be extended to digital technology, says the council’s report.

It says digital industries will soon represent a $3tn (£1.9tn) market.

The report wants to target support at creative, digital and information technology (CDIT) subjects – with the aim of cultivating businesses in digital industries of the future.

It says that the development of Silicon Valley, which provided a cradle for computer industries in the United States, was underpinned by public investment.

The government and funding authorities have made a priority of Stem subjects – science, technology, engineering and maths – including additional university places.

This has been in recognition of the subjects’ strategic importance for the economy.

But the Council for Industry and Higher Education (CIHE) says the UK now needs to invest in the development of digital industries.

Otherwise the report’s editor, David Docherty, says the UK risks “trailing behind countries such as China, the US, Japan and Australia”.

“The fusion of technology with the creative and digital industries is as vital to the UK’s economic growth as that of science, engineering and manufacturing”

Council for Industry and Higher Education

Mike Short, O2’s vice president of research and development, says that digital industries require skills and types of creativity that cross boundaries between arts and sciences.

“We know that these businesses are going to be very important,” he says, but they do not fit within any “rigid boundaries” between Stem subjects and the arts.

Digital businesses are a fusion of entertainment, engineering, retailing, design, technology and art – and as such need a different kind of support from the backing given to Stem subjects.

As such the report urges support for inter-disciplinary university projects – including arts and humanities, which integrate with science and technology in digital businesses.

The report calls for start-ups to be given research and development tax credits and public investment to help encourage private funding.

It also calls for universities and their students to work more closely with small and medium-sized creative digital companies.

At school level it calls for a shake-up of the ICT curriculum which it accuses of “holding back” the development of creative digital industries.

“The fusion of technology with the creative and digital industries is as vital to the UK’s economic growth as that of science, engineering and manufacturing,” says the report.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

UN ‘failed’ DR Congo rape victims

Village of Luvungi. 6 Sept 2010Luvungi was targeted by Hutu rebels who subjected villagers to systematic rape and violence

UN peacekeepers have “failed” the victims of mass rape in eastern DR Congo, a senior UN official has said.

Atul Khare told the Security Council that the scale of systematic rape by armed rebels was far worse than feared.

He said that up to 500 women and children were now believed raped in recent weeks – more than double the previously reported figure.

He called for the prosecution of Rwandan and Congolese rebels who are blamed for many of the attacks.

“At the same time a concerted response from the government, from the international community is needed to maintain pressure on the perpetrators of these rapes and to bring them to justice,” he told the BBC’s World Today programme.

Mr Khare, UN Assistant Secretary-General for Peacekeeping, was sent to DR Congo by UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon to investigate the attacks in July and August.

He reported to the Security Council that although 242 rapes had earlier been reported in and around Luvungi, a village not far from a UN peacekeepers’ camp, 260 more rapes had come to light in the Uvira area and other regions of North and South Kivu.

Mr Khare said he had learned of 74 attacks in a village called Miki, in South Kivu. The victims included 21 children – all girls aged between seven and 15 – and six men.

All the women in another village, Kiluma, may have been systematically raped, he said.

“While the primary responsibility for protection of civilians lies with the state, its national army and police force, clearly, we have also failed,” he said.

“Our actions were not adequate, resulting in acceptable brutalisation of the population of the villages in the area. We must do better.”

“Graphic examples were provided to me by the victims themselves when I met them in Luvungi and in other parts where I travelled. And I must say that this is why I feel that we have a responsibility, we owe a responsibility to the victims to make their lives better but also we owe them the responsibility of making DRC better,” Mr Khare told the BBC.

Mr Khare and the UN’s special envoy on sexual violence, Margot Wallstrom, suggested that Rwandan Hutu FDLR rebel chiefs might be among those responsible for organising the rapes in Luvungi.

“I would recommend… for consideration by the (Security) Council, imposition of targeted sanctions on the leaders of the FDLR, both within and outside the country, if a chain of command is proven,” Mr Khare said.

He added that UN peacekeepers will make more night patrols and perform more random checks on communities.

Mr Khare said the UN was also looking into ways of providing peacekeepers with mobile phones by installing a high frequency radio in Luvungi.

The BBC’s Thomas Hubert, in Goma, said the Congolese government was pleased to see the UN shoulder some of the responsibility for failing to stop human rights abuses, but disappointed that there was no stronger commitment to tackle rebel groups.

Government spokesman Lamert Mende called on the UN to support its national army more directly against the militias.

He urged peacekeepers to “do the dirty work” and “move to the front”.

The latest mass rapes – during July and August – were first reported by the International Medical Corps, which treated many of the victims.

Mr Ban sent his envoys to the country to learn why UN peacekeepers had apparently been unaware of the attacks.

DR Congo has a shocking reputation for sexual violence, and rape is commonly used as a weapon of war.

The UN says at least 8,300 rapes were reported in 2009 and it is believed that many more attacks go unreported.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Call for morning sickness action

PregnantMorning sickness is a common problem in pregnancy

More needs to be done to establish which are safe and effective ways to relieve morning sickness, experts say.

There is reluctance to use pharmaceutical products in pregnancy due to Thalidomide, the 1960s anti-nausea drug which led to birth defects.

But there is little evidence to suggest that alternative therapies have any real impact, the international group of researchers Cochrane found.

Campaigners say women who suffer receive a “Cinderella service”.

Despite its name, the vomiting and nausea of morning sickness can occur at any time of the day and affect about half of pregnant women.

About two in 100 will experience it so badly they need to be hospitalised.

Ginger biscuits

Cochrane researchers looked at nearly 30 strictly controlled trials involving more than 4,000 women who were up to 20 weeks pregnant.

They examined six studies of acupressure and two of acupuncture, and found these methods offered no significant benefit.

One study of acustimulation – the mild electrical stimulation of acupuncture points – did document some improvement.

“It is not possible currently to identify with confidence any safe and effective interventions for nausea and vomiting in early pregnancy”

Dr Anne Matthews, Dublin City University

There was limited evidence for ginger, which is used in various forms from biscuits to tablets, or for vitamin B6.

There was also little evidence on the efficacy of antihistamines and anti-vomiting drugs including Debendox, which was withdrawn from the market in the UK but is routinely prescribed in Canada.

That does not mean these methods do not work, but that women – and health professionals – do not have any reliable evidence on which to make their judgements about the best treatments.

In the UK, there are currently no pharmaceutical products specifically licensed for use with pregnant women, but doctors who do prescribe for severe sickness tend to offer the antihistamines promethazine and cyclizines.

“Despite the wealth of different treatments available, it is not possible currently to identify with confidence any safe and effective interventions for nausea and vomiting in early pregnancy,” said lead researcher Dr Anne Matthews, of the School of Nursing at Dublin City University.

“The difficulties in interpreting the results of the studies highlight the need for further, more rigorous trials in this area.”

Dr Brian Swallow, a health psychologist and member of Pregnancy Sickness Support, said: “At present treatment varies according to the woman’s geographical location.

“Some areas are very good, whereas others have not developed appropriate treatment protocols. There is very little research that that aims to help women with nausea and vomiting in pregnancy.

“In terms of treatments, the most effective appear to be anti-nausea medication. GPs are often reluctant to administer them because they are fearful that they may have harmful effects on the foetus – although there is no evidence to suggest that they have.”

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Job market growth slows in August

Nurses at workThere are some sectors with job shortages, according to Rec

Job appointments grew at their slowest rate in 10 months in August, raising further questions about the strength of the UK job market, a survey suggests.

The Recruitment and Employment Confederation (Rec) said both permanent and temporary placements rose at the weakest rate since October 2009.

Growth in pay also continued to slow, Rec said.

“Growth [in the UK’s jobs market] is rapidly slowing as public sector job freezes start to bite,” it added.

The body did, however, find that there were opportunities in some sectors, such as chefs, nurses, engineers and internet developers, where there were a shortage of skilled workers.

“A priority for government is to ramp up the support and guidance for job-seekers and to raise awareness of these growth areas within our labour market,” said Rec’s chief executive Kevin Green.

The latest figures show that the number of unemployed people in the UK fell by 49,000 in the three months to the end of June, to 2.46 million.

However, a number of analysts expect that number to rise in the coming months as a result of public sector job losses that will result from government spending cuts designed to reduce the country’s budget deficit.

“Whereas demand for staff is growing in the private sector, many public sector organisations have started redundancy programmes,” said Bernard Brown at KPMG, which produced the survey with Rec.

“In the months ahead we will see a substantial reduction in public sector headcount as the cuts begin to bite.

“The big question is whether the private sector can create new jobs in sufficient numbers and quickly enough to offset the downturn in the public sector.”

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Soros gives $100m to rights group

George SorosMr Soros said that HRW was one of the most effective organisations he supported

George Soros is to donate $100m (£65m) to Human Rights Watch (HRW) over the next 10 years, the investor and philanthropist has announced.

“Human Rights Watch is one of the most effective organisations I support,” Mr Soros said.

The gift from Soros’s Open Society Foundations is the largest the billionaire has made to a non-governmental organisation, HRW said.

It is given under the condition that HRW raises another $100m.

Related stories

The gift is the first in a series of large donations he plans to make, Mr Soros said in an interview with the New York Times.

“This is partly due to age,” the 80-year-old added.

“Originally I wanted to distribute all of the money during my lifetime, but I have abandoned that plan.”

HRW is to use the money to hire more staff and expand its work internationally, the group said in a statement.

The plan requires HRW to increase its annual budget from $48m to $80m within five years, the organisation added.

HRW, which is based in New York, currently has a staff of almost 300 and a presence in nearly 90 countries.

In October, Forbes Magazine estimated Mr Soros’s fortune at $14bn (£9.1bn).

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Two-tier university warning given

GraduatesFewer students will study on campus, vice-chancellors warn.

The traditional residential university experience could become the preserve of an elite, vice-chancellors are warning.

As universities struggle to cope with outdated funding models, more students will end up learning remotely and part-time, a Universities UK report says.

This may lead to a clear social divide between those receiving two different forms of higher education, it says.

It also warns ministers against decisions that will hurt long-term.

In a report for the vice-chancellors’ body, UUK, published ahead of its conference, Prof Geoffrey Crossick says the current model for delivering higher education has been “inherited from the past when it was available to the very few”.

And the University of London vice-chancellor argues the system is not financially sustainable and in need of radical reform.

“If mass higher education is too costly for it all to be delivered in traditional ways and with traditional funding, and if the changing demands of the economy require far more flexibility, then a much more diverse system will emerge,” he says.

He predicts the range of alternatives will “explode” and that the variety of providers will grow too.

“There will remain a core of comprehensive, primarily residential and (most of them) research-based universities, but for the rest new markets and new business models will make them seem increasingly different.”

He adds: “Higher education as a life-course stage will narrow to just one part of the population who experience it.”

The rest would get their learning in a range of new ways including distance learning, studying in small modules and from a myriad of providers.

But he says there have to be real concerns about the consequences of these changes for social mobility.

Prof Crossick says: “The division may no longer be between those who get a higher education and those who don’t, but between those who get a higher education in a comprehensive traditional university and those who access it through a myriad of providers in often small learning modules.

“Both will be needed by the economy and society, both will be of major benefit to the student and graduate.

“But unless we think about the issues now as we imagine the new system, we might end up with a clear social dividing line between the two forms of receiving higher education.”

He acknowledges that universities have to be less costly, but warns against doing things because they are cheap.

If cost is the determining factor, he warns “we may well in 10 years’ time deeply regret the wasted opportunity to produce the higher education system” that is required for the future.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Miss! Pick me

Girl with hand up in class

No more raised hands to answer questions, and a short, sharp burst of PE first thing every day. It’s school – with a difference.

The more usual scenario is repeated in classrooms everywhere. Teacher asks a question. A few hands shoot up – always the same hands. The hands that aren’t raised instead prop up drooping heads, or twiddle pens.

Find out moreGareth Malone’s Extraordinary School for Boys is on BBC Two from Thursday 9 Sept, 2100 BSTAnd Dylan Wiliam’s The Classroom Experiment will be broadcast mid-SeptemberOr watch with the iPlayer More in the School season

Those who raise their hands listen in class, engage with the topic and so achieve more highly. The others, often, let their attention drift. “They’re foregoing the opportunity to get smarter,” says education expert Dylan Wiliam.

And so he banned hands-up when he took over a Year 8 class of 12 and 13-year-olds at Hertswood School, a Hertfordshire comprehensive, for the summer term. The pupils were guinea pigs, testing methods for grabbing – and holding – the attention of the whole class, not just the usual suspects.

Boys in particular can lag behind, so in another experiment for the BBC, choirmaster Gareth Malone turned teacher for a term at Pear Tree Mead Primary in Essex, to try to re-engage boys who don’t like school. He taught the nine- to 11-year-olds outdoors, with running around and role-play in a clearing in the school grounds.

So what did they do – and why?

NO HANDS-UP – EXCEPT TO ASK A QUESTION

Children hold up slatesSlates – in hi-tech form – worked well

“When teachers ask questions, it’s always the same few pupils who put up their hands. The others can slip below the teacher’s radar, and therefore tune out,” says Professor Wiliam.

So instead of a show of hands, the teacher would ask pupils at random to answer any questions. There was resistance at first.

“Those who didn’t usually raise their hands were shocked that they had to pay attention. Those used to volunteering an answer were nonplussed by their removal from the spotlight,” he says.

Teachers found they had to plan their lessons in more detail, formulating questions to draw out pupils who’d fallen out of the habit of responding in class.

A compromise was for the teacher to randomly pick two pupils to answer, then ask if anyone had anything to add, giving habitual answerers a chance to pitch in.

By far the most successful way to engage the whole class was to issue mini-whiteboards on which each pupil wrote their answer – an innovation being rolled out school-wide this term.

“Mini-whiteboards are standard issue in many schools, but are usually left in a cupboard.

“It’s the return of the slate. Two hundred years ago, the best teachers were getting every child to write their answers on slates,” says Professor William.

PE TO START THE DAY

Pupils on a runIt can take as long to get in and out of PE kit

Children can veer from lethargy to fizzing with energy in the blink of an eye. So how about a burst of activity first thing to wake everyone up?

Physical education is part of the national curriculum, but many schools struggle to make time for it.

“Pupils spend a lot of time writing, and very little time getting out of breath. But research shows increasing oxygen levels in the brain can boost alertness,” says Professor Wiliam.

To shoehorn in 10 minutes of PE first thing, his pupils had to start school earlier to allow time for changing in and out of sports gear.

Dylan Wiliam

“Pupils spend a lot of time writing, and very little time getting out of breath”

Dylan William

This proved unpopular.

“It was only 10 minutes earlier, which they thought was a big deal and an impingement on their personal freedom. But some felt it made them more alert in morning lessons.”

Exercises before school or work were popular early last century, with exponents including the Bauhaus arts and design group.

At Hertswood School, the extra PE took the form of curcuit training, with pupils rotating through activities such as sprinting, skipping and bench steps. Particularly successful were the sessions supervised by older pupils taking sport as an elective.

“Often this would be quite an athletic boy. The boys would compete against his time, and the girls would try harder to impress him.”

TAKE IT OUTSIDE

Gareth Malone and his pupilsGareth and the boys in their woodland classroom

Gareth Malone also introduced more movement into the school day at Pear Tree Mead Primary, by setting up an outdoor classroom.

With the hesitant blessing of the head teacher, he and the boys cleared a space in an overgrown wooded corner of the school grounds.

As well as lessons in this den, he encouraged rivalry and running around to see if their minds responded to being free-range.

The boys bellowed The Highwayman in the open air before chasing down Malone, dressed in breeches and cape, to put him on trial for robbery.

The aim was to improve their verbal skills – important for literacy – with the added incentive of a boys v girls debate.

Using outdoor desks as exercise equipment at high school in 1929Exercises before an open-air lesson in 1929

After years of non-competitive activities in which all must have prizes, is competition due a comeback in schools? Professor Wiliam says yes – if handled carefully.

“You’ve got to pitch it at just above their level.

“That’s why the rivalry between Steve Ovett and Sebastian Coe was genuniely healthy – they were so close in ability, they pushed each other to do better. If it was me racing against one of them, I wouldn’t compete, I’d give up.”

Competition works best when pupils are in groups, he says, to encourage collaboration within the team and competition against their rivals.

NO GRADES GIVEN

Boy doing homework in kitchen with motherAre we hooked on scores?

A. B+. B-. C. F. What did you get?

“The first thing pupils do is look at their score. Do you know what the second thing is? Look at what the others got. Any feedback from the teacher is ignored,” says Professor Wiliam. “As soon as you grade them, learning stops.”

So in his experimental classroom, projects were returned with no grades, just feedback. In an art lesson, for instance, pupils made gecko sculptures and were given written feedback on how to improve on their creation. Only once it had been reworked did their gecko get graded.

“They didn’t like it. Pupils are like drug addicts, they’re addicted to grades and we’ve got them hooked. They expect grades. Parents expect grades.”

So did the pupils eventually respond to this, and other methods tried by Professor Wiliam?

“I was genuinely surprised that we managed to have a noticable impact on their achievement – and at how much more confident they were.”

Gareth Malone will also be interviewed on BBC Two’s Newsnight on Thursday 9 September at 2230 BST

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Don’t knows

Don't know

In his regular Go Figure column, Michael Blastland looks at why the people ignored by surveys could be those with the strongest opinions of all.

I’d like you to complete the following questionnaire.

Do surveys of opinion ask sensible questions?

a. Yes

b. No

c. Don’t know

d. No Answer

Do surveys of opinion allow sensible answers?

a. Yes

b. No

c. Don’t know

d. No Answer

Which answers are most instructive about public opinion?

a. Yes or No

b. Don’t Know

c. No Answer

Michael Blastland

“But when an issue is real, specific and maybe here and now, the don’t knows and don’t cares can quickly change”

Michael Blastland

Only asking. After all, people are asked what they think about all sorts of things. Is climate change unstoppable? Are tax rises are a good idea? Does extra-terrestrial life exist? Should we build more roads?

I don’t know about you, but quite often there seems to me only one sensible answer the questions posed in these attempts to canvass opinion: I don’t know.

But that’s not really what I mean. What I really mean is: “it depends”. And for that reason, I might not answer.

Yet the standard way for pollsters to treat people like me is to ignore them.

“Excluding don’t-knows and no answers” say the reports, before telling us that most of us think we should or shouldn’t do this or that. It’s as if the “don’t knows” haven’t been paying attention while the “no answers” don’t care.

Strip out the apathetic and the ignorant and see what’s left, they seem to say.

But isn’t it at least arguable that we’ve thought about it and decided uncertainty is the best response?

Tax rises? When, for who, how much, for how long, for what purpose? Maybe, maybe not. It depends.

Ricky Gervais dressed as alienBelieve in aliens?

Climate change unstoppable? Now where did I put my crystal ball and my vast science library?

Alien life-forms? Unless you’ve bumped into one lately, withholding judgement seems reasonable enough.

Maarten Hajer, an academic, says that apart from holding reasonable doubts, many people are “citizens on standby”. They don’t show up in surveys, but they are “people with many political skills… who are not necessarily interested in employing them”.

That passivity can change in an instant. Those who “[show] up in surveys as ‘not interested in politics’, they can transform overnight into activists”.

The “don’t cares” and “don’t knows” may appear meek and mild in the abstract conditions of a survey. But when an issue is real, specific and maybe here and now, they can quickly change to “do care” and “do know”.

In short, it depends. But as to whether these people are apathetic or ignorant? They may be. They may be anything but. And if you want to know what might turn citizens on standby into active citizens with strong opinions… ask the don’t knows.

Switch that light off

From time to time, Go Figure promises to show smart ways of seeing numbers. If you’ve somehow missed it elsewhere, the DECC 2050 energy calculator is worth looking up. There are 134 options for you to play with to change the way we provide and consume energy in the UK: how much land we use for bio energy, how many nuclear power stations we have, what each option does to greenhouse gases and so on. It’s worth watching the video first to see how the calculator works. It’s all accessible from the 2050 Calculator Tool website

Graphic

For me, it’s equally interesting about the potential for technology to help public argument when it involves quantifiable options: let people play with those options, see the consequences as best we understand them – immediately – and come to their own conclusions.

Here’s a screen grab showing just a few of the options. And if you are tempted to have a closer look, here’s a little challenge for you: see how much difference you can make to projected UK energy demand by changing people’s behaviour.

Whether you believe climate change is real, man-made or not, you might well find this a clever way of encouraging people to engage with the policy problems of energy supply and consumption.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

More obesity ops ‘will save cash’

Thermogram of obese peopleSurgery should be a last resort, says the government

Millions of pounds is lost in England by the failure of the NHS to provide more obesity operations, a study says.

About 1m people meet the criteria for bariatric surgery, but last year there were just 3,600 operations carried out.

The Office of Health Economics suggests £1.3bn could be saved over three years if a quarter of eligible patients got treatment through more people working and fewer demands on the NHS.

But the government said the treatment should always be a “last resort”.

The economists looked at a range of data in their analysis, including official guidelines, figures from more than half of NHS trusts and previously published reports.

‘Huge variation’

The research – which was funded by two firms involved in making equipment used in obesity surgery – suggests that one in four of the 1m eligible patients are ready for and want surgery.

If all those went under the knife, the report says, £1.7bn would be gained in working time while an extra £104m would be saved by the NHS not having to deal with the ill-health associated with being obese.

Once the £546m cost of the treatments is then taken into account, it claims, the saving stands at £1.3bn. The figure would be even greater if the saving made on benefits is taken into account, the authors add.

“Surgery can literally transform people’s lives in a way that no other treatment is able to, getting them back to work and contributing fully to society”

Peter Sedman Bariatric surgeon

Even if this was not possible and only 5% got the treatment, £382m would be saved over three years, the report says.

Bariatric surgery covers a range of different procedures.

Gastric banding involves reducing the size of the stomach with a band fitted around it, while a gastric bypass reroutes food to a small stomach pouch created by surgeons.

A third, less frequently used procedure, removes a portion of the stomach.

While treatments have been increasing – in the past decade by ten times – there is a huge variation in what is offered by different NHS trusts.

The data obtained by the researchers found one in 10 ignored official guidance about who should be eligible for treatment, while half only used elements of this guidance.

It means that the numbers going under the knife vary from 192 in one trust to just one in another.

Often the situation is blamed on money, with obesity surgery being one of the first areas to be cut when money is tight.

Dr David Haslam of the National Obesity Forum, which commissioned the research along with the Royal College of Surgeons, said the government needed to improve access to treatment.

Peter Sedman, a leading bariatric surgeon and member of the Association of Laparoscopic Surgeons, added: “Surgery can literally transform people’s lives in a way that no other treatment is able to, getting them back to work and contributing fully to society.”

The Department of Health said bariatric surgery should always be a “last resort” and instead it was encouraging people to pursue healthier lifestyles so this type of treatment was not necessary.

But a spokeswoman added the NHS still had a duty to ensure patients had access to the right care.

“It is up to individual trusts to commission a range of services to meet their local community’s needs.”

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Statins ‘may cut arthritis risk’

Rheumatoid arthritisRheumatoid arthritis can be extremely debilitating

Taking statins may reduce the risk of rheumatoid arthritis, a study suggests.

Israeli researchers looked at 1.8m patients and found fewer incidents of the joint condition among those who took the cholesterol-busting drugs.

It was thought statins could ease symptoms in those already diagnosed by stopping the over-production of tissue between the joints.

But the Maccabi Healthcare Services Research Institute study suggested they could stop it developing altogether.

The team discovered 2,500 cases of rheumatoid arthritis, the debilitating inflammation of the joints which affects about one in 100 people.

Heart and joints

They found that those people who were on statins, now commonly prescribed to prevent heart attacks, were 50% less likely to develop the condition than those who were not regularly taking the drugs.

The relationship in this trial between adherence to statin therapy and incidence of rheumatoid arthritis is unclear, but the work builds on existing knowledge.

However, the researchers acknowledged that the work, published in the journal PLOS Medicine, now needed to be confirmed in other populations.

Jane Tadman, of Arthritis Research UK, said: “Our own published research and that of researchers in Japan has shown a modest but significant effect on inflammation in rheumatoid arthritis, and this latest piece of research adds further evidence of this link.

“We now need larger clinical trials to confirm further that statins can reduce the risk of developing rheumatoid arthritis.”

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Nasa’s health tip to Chile miners

Dr Michael Duncan (left) and other Nasa experts speak during a news conference in HoustonNasa experts advised the Chilean miners to form an “underground community”

Experts from America’s space agency Nasa have been speaking about tips they gave 33 trapped Chilean miners to keep up their psychological health.

They said they advised the miners – trapped at the San Jose mine since 5 August – to regulate the number of times they spoke to their families.

The experts also said the miners should form an “underground community”.

In the latest attempt to maintain morale, the miners watched a live feed of the Chilean football team in action.

Rescues dropped a mini-TV screen connected to a fibre-optic cable down the narrow supply chute – the only link the miners have with the outside world.

However, Chile lost their match against Ukraine in Kiev 2-1.

Meanwhile, engineers are continuing to drill two rescue tunnels to try to reach the miners trapped at 700m (2,300ft) below the ground. The work is expected to take between two and four months.

After visiting the mine, Nasa experts said they advised the miners to form an “underground community” as they faced a “long period of time” before they could be rescued.

“I think the Chileans had not gotten to that point of thinking how difficult this post rescue effort is going to be”

Dr Michael Duncan Nasa expert

“It’s going to be a group of people that live underground for a long period of time and there will be roles and responsibilities that are allocated and just like topside, just like us, sometimes if we tire of our role or we need a change then we are able to swap with someone else, rotate out, and they will be doing that as well,” Nasa psychologist Albert Holland said at a news conference in Houston.

“So, organisation and focus is a big part of normality, it’s a big part of social structure and community. And, we have to expect though, that they are going to have their ups and downs, just like we do,” he added.

Dr Michael Duncan, the head of the Nasa team, warned that “this is going to be a very dynamic situation for a long period of time and I am sure they will have questions and want to bounce ideas off of us, some things that we have learned”.

“Really the work is just beginning when the miners come out of the mine, because there is a lot of rehabilitation and recovery that the miners will have to go through.

Trapped miner Claudio Yanez speaks to his wife and daughter via video conferenceThe families were able to speak to their families via video conference for the first time last Saturday

“There is the reintroduction of the miner to the family; there’s the reintroduction of the miner to society.

Dr Duncan also warned that the miners – who will have “a certain celebrity status in Chile” – would also face a lot of pressure by society and the media after the rescue.

“I think the Chileans had not gotten to that point of thinking how difficult this post rescue effort is going to be.”

The Nasa experts also said that their participation in the rescue and rehabilitation effort might produce benefits for future space missions.

The miners have become national heroes in Chile since 22 August, when a drill probe reached the underground shelter where they had survived for 17 days without contact with the outside world.

Many had given them up for lost, but they had kept alive underground by rationing emergency food supplies.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.