The historians’ letter was organised by Tory MP Chris Skidmore
Related Stories
A group of leading historians have voiced their opposition to altering the UK voting system while several senior businessmen have called for change.
Niall Ferguson, Anthony Beevor and Andrew Roberts are among those who say a switch to the Alternative Vote (AV) would harm democratic principles.
But the chairman of insurer Aviva and other executives said moving to AV would be a “victory for fairness”.
A referendum on the change will be held on 5 May.
In a letter to The Times, 25 historians argue that the current first-past-the-post voting system for Westminster elections is the product of a long fight for one vote for every man or woman in the country regardless of wealth, gender, race or creed.
They claim this principle of “equal votes” would be threatened by a move to AV – where voters rank candidates in order of preference and second preference votes given to the candidate with the least support are re-distributed after the initial ballot if no-one gains over 50% of first preference votes.
THE REFERENDUM CHOICE
At the moment MPs are elected by the first-past-the-post system, where the candidate getting the most votes in a constituency is elected.
On 5 May all registered UK voters will be able to vote Yes or No on whether to change the way MPs are elected to the Alternative Vote system.
Under the Alternative Vote system, voters rank candidates in their constituency in order of preference.
Anyone getting more than 50% of first-preference votes is elected.
If no-one gets 50% of votes, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated and their backers’ second choices allocated to those remaining.
This process continues until one candidate has at least 50% of all votes in that round.
Referendum views: Yes campaign Referendum views: No campaign
The letter was conceived by the historian turned Conservative MP Chris Skidmore – the author of a number of books on the British monarchy – and not organised by the official No to AV campaign.
Its other signatories include the Regius Professor of History at Cambridge Richard Evans and the best-selling writer Professor Anthony Beevor.
“The cause of reform, so long fought for, cannot afford to have the fundamentally fair and historic principle of majority voting cast aside,” the historians write.
“Nor should we sacrifice the principle which generations of men and women have sought: that each being equal, every member of our society should cast an equal vote.”
At the same time, 11 leading businessmen have endorsed AV in a rival letter to the Daily Telegraph – in a move which was independent of the official Yes to Fairer votes campaign.
The signatories, who include Aviva chairman Lord Sharman, Home Retail Group boss Terry Duddy and top corporate PR executive Roland Rudd, said they were speaking in a private capacity.
AV would make MPs “work harder” to get elected, they claimed, as they would need to aim to secure a majority of voters’ support in their constituency.
“Parties would have to pay far more attention to the vast majority of people during election campaigns under AV,” they write.
The current system forced parties to “sacrifice stability for short-term electoral gain”, they add, and AV elections would give “greater legitimacy” to political parties.
“A vote for change on 5 May would be a victory for fairness, a break with a system of the past and a foundation for greater political stability. It would be good for the country and good for business.”
Voters will go to the polls in the first UK-wide referendum since 1975 on 5 May.
This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.
