Foreign aid fraud warning issued

A Polio victim in IndiaThe level of aid to India will be frozen under plans revealed by the government last month
Related Stories

Government foreign aid chiefs must improve efforts to identify potential fraud, the National Audit Office says.

The spending watchdog said the UK had no clear picture of the “extent, nature and impact” of development funds failing to meet goals due to fraud.

It said value for money was more important than ever.

International Development Secretary Andrew Mitchell has announced that aid will in future be targeted more at war-torn and “fragile” states.

But the National Audit Office (NAO) said such countries were more likely to be beset by poor governance and corruption, heightening the need to ensure money arrived where it was intended.

All nine of the countries where spending is due to be increased by more than 50% are among the worst on that score, according to a leading anti-corruption body.

In its report on financial management at the Department for International Development, the NAO concluded the current approach was “too reactive and cannot provide Parliament and the taxpayer with a clear picture of the extent, nature and impact of leakage”.

It went on to say the risk of “leakage… will potentially increase as the spending increases for those countries with less developed controls and capability”.

Spending on aid is set to rise by £3.3bn over four years to meet a United Nations target for wealthy nations to spend 0.7% of GDP on development by 2013.

And the Department for International Development’s overall £7.8bn budget has been unaffected by the government’s deficit-cutting measures.

NAO head Amyas Morse said: “This report shows considerable progress is being made, but a better information environment is needed to deal with the heightened levels of assurance required in targeting future aid at higher-risk locations.”

Mr Mitchell said that the report had made some “good points”.

“From day one of the coalition government, we set about making fundamental changes to British development policy – for example setting up an independent aid watchdog and pioneering results-based aid.”

Last month the government outlined plans to stop direct development aid to 16 countries and freeze the level of assistance given to India.

The countries that will no longer receive direct aid, including Russia, China, Vietnam, Serbia and Iraq. Some, such as Vietnam and Bosnia, are seen to have “graduated” out of poverty.

But there will be more for Bangladesh, Nigeria and Pakistan as aid is “tightly focused” on those considered to be most in need.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Clothes shop criticised over ‘provocative’ catalogue

Part of image from Jack Wills catalogueThe ASA criticised an image of a topless couple kissing while being sprayed with water
Related Stories

Clothing retailer Jack Wills has been told by the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) not to reprint its spring catalogue in its current form.

Nineteen people complained that four of the pictures in it were unsuitable for a catalogue targeted at teenagers.

The Devon-based company responded that the brand was aimed at university students over the age of 18.

But the ASA concluded that the catalogue was sufficiently provocative to present a risk to younger teenagers.

The company said that people wishing to receive their catalogue would have had to sign up online or in stores and in either case would have had to confirm that they were over 18.

It said that its logo described it as the “University Outfitters” and added that the pictures were supposed to project “a positive, fun and sometimes flirtatious” reflection of student life.

Two years ago, the ASA cleared a semi-naked image in the Jack Wills catalogue, saying that it was not provocative enough to present a risk to teenagers or be unsuitable for the target audience.

This time though, the ASA adjudication ruled that some of the images went beyond what could be considered to be fun or flirtatious.

It was particularly concerned about an image of a topless couple kissing while being sprayed with water.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

US warning on Pakistan militancy

Pakistani paramilitary troops take position on a hilltop post in Khajore Kut, a tribal area in South Waziristan (file photo)US says Pakistan is avoiding direct conflict with the militants in the tribal areas

Pakistan still has no “clear path” to defeat militants on its soil, a new White House has said.

The report also said the Afghan Taliban had begun targeting civilian targets in recent months and that “heavy fighting” was expected this spring.

Pakistan has come under increasing criticism from the West for its support of al-Qaeda and Taliban militants.

In January, a US strategic review of the war said Pakistan must do more to defeat the militants.

Pakistan has repeatedly rejected claims that it is dragging its feet in the fight against militancy. It says that it works hard with the US in the “war against terror”.

The White House report said that in spite of “tremendous human sacrifices” made by Pakistani security forces and increased military co-operation between Pakistan and US in the last three months, the fight against militancy was making little progress.

Pakistani troops in Bannu (file picture)The US has long expressed frustration about the army’s reluctance to take on militants

It cites the example of an operation to clear insurgents from Mohmand and Bajaur tribal agencies that began in January – the third time in two years – and has been hobbled by resistance from the militants, bad weather and the need to settle internally displaced people.

“What remains vexing is the lack of any indication of ‘hold’ and ‘build’ planning or staging efforts to complement ongoing clearing operations,” the report said.

“As such there remains no clear path to defeating the insurgency in Pakistan, despite the unprecedented and sustained deployment of over 147,000 forces.”

The White House report says that Pakistan and Afghanistan needed to co-operate more to destroy insurgent havens on both sides of the border.

The report also warned that the rising number of suicide attacks in Afghanistan in recent months pointed to the beginning of this year’s “fighting season” in the country.

It also appeared to suggest a shift in Taliban’s tactics against “softer government and civilian targets”.

“The shift in the Taliban’s greater use of murder and intimidation tactics reflects an insurgency under the pressure of a more substantive coalition military campaign,” the report said.

“That said, there are also indications that the Taliban remains confident of its strategy and resources, and heavy fighting is expected to resume this spring.”

The US has long expressed frustration about Pakistan’s reluctance to take on militants in the tribal areas.

In a report in October, the White House accused the Pakistani military of continuing to avoid military engagements that would put it in direct conflict with Afghan Taliban or al-Qaeda forces in North Waziristan.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

7 questions

Midweek quiz

The price of a first-class stamp has shot up by an inflation-busting 5p. The cost of stamps and of pints of milk are classic measures of being in touch with reality. So test yourself on the prices of everyday items.

Postie delivering letters

1.) Multiple Choice Question

So after the 5p rise, how much is a first-class stamp now?

First-class stamps 36p41p46p

2.) Multiple Choice Question

Just one of these foods costs the same now as it did a year ago. Which one?

Bananas and other items Bananas, per kgLoaf of sliced whitePint of milk1kg of sugar

3.) Multiple Choice Question

Speaking of bread, wheat prices have risen more than 80% in the past year. The average price for a loaf of sliced white is up 1p – but is the price change for wholemeal loaves…

Brown breads MoreLessThe same

4.) Multiple Choice Question

Milk in your cuppa? Tea bags and instant coffee are both in the ONS’s sample basket of goods used to track inflation. Which is cheapest?

Pints of milk in glass bottles Tea bags – box of 80Instant coffee – 100g jar

5.) Multiple Choice Question

The cost of keeping the radiators warm, the lights on and the taps running in our homes is on the up. Which utility has risen the most since 2005?

Gas hob GasElectricityWater

6.) Multiple Choice Question

England is now the only part of the UK to still charge for prescriptions – and the fee has gone up. What is it now?

Man holding prescription in pharmacy bag £7.40£7.20£6.50£5.90

7.) Multiple Choice Question

Inflation is currently 4.4%, more than double the official target of 2%. But “everyday inflation” – items households consume most regularly – is 5.4%. Which has gone up the most?

FuelHome repairsCar insuranceFood

Answers

First-class stamps are now 46p, up from 41p. And second-class stamps have risen by 4p to 36p. It’s milk – it averaged 44p a pint in February 2010, and averaged 44p a pint a year later, according to the most recent Office of National Statistics (ONS) figures. Bananas are cheaper by 10p a kg; but sugar and loaves of bread are more expensive. It’s the same. The average price of wholemeal loaves is also up 1p from February 2010 to 2011, says the ONS. It’s tea bags, average price £1.92 for 80 compared to £2.47 for 100g of pure instant coffee. Gas prices have risen the most – up almost 89% since 2005 on the Consumer Prices Index. Water is up about 30%, and electricity 60%. It’s now £7.40. On 1 April, Scotland abolished its £3 charge to join Wales and Northern Ireland in having free prescriptions. In England, it rose by 20p – although medicines are free for children, those on low incomes, and sufferers of some chronic diseases. It’s car insurance, up 29% in a year, according to research by PricewaterhouseCoopers. Food is up 5.7%, fuel up 15.9% and home repairs up 9.3%.

Your Score

0 – 3 : Butler do your shopping?

4 – 6 : BOGOF

7 – 7 : Chancellor of the household

For past quizzes including our weekly news quiz, 7 days 7 questions, expand the grey drop-down below – also available on the Magazine page (and scroll down).

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

‘Patients denied cancer drugs’

Nurses on hospital wardThe report claims 22 drugs are available to patients in England but not in Wales
Related Stories

A new report claims 30 Welsh patients have been denied potentially life-prolonging cancer drugs on the NHS.

Another 91 had to apply for funds for treatment recommended by a doctor using “exceptional case procedures” as it was not routinely available.

The figures have come to light under Freedom of Information requests by the Rarer Cancers Foundation (RCF).

The assembly government said the next administration will consider the report’s finding and recommendations.

The report by RCF, Exceptional Cymru?, claims there are currently 22 drugs which are not available to patients in Wales but that doctors in England can apply for on behalf of patients.

It said the 30 Welsh patients were denied funding for treatment between October 2009 and December 2010 after the NHS “refused to pay for drugs which could have prolonged their lives”.

“The NHS should be there when you need it the most, but this is sadly not the case for all cancer patients in Wales ”

Andrew Wilson Rarer Cancers Foundation

They had made their application to their local health board which pays for NHS treatment on their behalf.

However, the report found approval rates for “exceptional case applications” is significantly lower in Wales (67%) than Scotland (87%).

It called the system “restrictive”, claiming it is “deterring” doctors from applying in Wales where they are six times less likely to make an exceptional case application than they are in Scotland.

RCF chief executive Andrew Wilson said: “The NHS should be there when you need it the most, but this is sadly not the case for all cancer patients in Wales.

“Access to treatment should be based on clinical need and not a lottery based on which side of the border you live.

He said the report provided proof that patients in Wales are being denied treatments which they would get elsewhere in the United Kingdom.

Mr Wilson callled on the assembly government to look at the evidence and “act now to fix this broken and unfair system.”

‘Exceptional circumstances’

Cancer treatments may not be routinely available to patients in Wales due to a number of circumstances.

A Welsh Assembly Government spokesperson said “all new drugs deemed clinically and cost effective” by NICE (National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence) or AWMSG (All Wales Medicines Strategy Group) “are made available on the NHS”.

“Where these drugs are not approved, or are waiting approval, mechanisms are in place to ensure consistent access for patients in exceptional circumstances,” said the spokesperson.

The Routledge Report – commissioned by the assembly health minister – was published in March 2009 with 11 recommendations aimed at improving the availability of medicines for people in Wales.

The RCF report, Exceptional Cymru?, makes 20 recommendations, including calling on the next Welsh Assembly Government to “publish a report on the progress made in implementing Professor Routledge’s recommendations and how they intend to build on this”.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Watching the holes

Julian Assange with leaked data, ReutersWikileaks has got many companies thinking about how to monitor data movements
Related Stories

Whistle-blowing website Wikileaks does not just spell trouble for the US government, Bank Julius Baer and the other companies, organisations and individuals that feature on the site.

Its mere existence and the appearance of many copycat sites is starting to occupy the minds of those who oversee security in every large company.

Why?

“Simple,” said Philippe Courtot, founder and chief executive of security firm Qualys, “because every company has something to hide.”

In most cases, he said, those secrets are just details of deals that are about to be signed, products under development or strategy changes. But also, he said, many firms have “dirty laundry” that would damage their reputation if it became public.

Wikileaks is tricky to defend against, said Mr Courtot, because the threat it poses is very diffuse and it comes from the inside. Before now, he said, corporates have put most of their time and money into defending themselves against external attack.

Spam filters, firewalls, anti-virus programs and intrusion detection systems are all about stopping the bad guys getting in. This makes sense because there are many millions of malicious programs and legions of cyber thieves endlessly trying to subvert employees and networks for profit.

Those defences are not entirely useless against the threats that Wikileaks pose, said Alex De Joode, security officer at hosting firm LeaseWeb.

They can come into play if supporters of Wikileaks take action in its name.

“What Wikileaks does is not really cyber crime,” said Mr De Joode, “The acts of the individuals who tried to make companies accountable for their actions against Wikileaks using denial of service attacks, that’s cyber crime.”

In Operation Payback, many Wikileaks supporters joined forces to bombard well-known web firms such as Paypal, Amazon and Visa with data in an attempt to knock them offline. The targets were chosen because the firms, in the eyes of those supporters, had not done enough to support Wikileaks.

At such times, said Mr De Joode, established defences work because they are designed to defend against precisely those types of attack.

Not all defences point outwards. Inside corporate networks there are also tools available to watch what employees are doing.

Mohan Koo, managing director of security firm Dtex, said it was possible to monitor every mouse click and key press employees make, no matter the size of the company.

Wikileaks supporters, PASecurity systems can defend against attacks carried out by Wikileaks supporters

“But,” he said, “no-one is going to do that because there’s just too much data.”

Equally wrong-headed, he said, was for a company worried by Wikileaks to clamp down on what their employees do online.

“A company might think they have locked it down and there’s nothing going on,” he said. “but all they have done is make people look for ways around the blocks.”

The statistics gathered by strict intranet monitoring tools might suggest that nothing nefarious was going on, he said.

In reality, security was likely to be compromised more because employees are using subterfuge to do the things they are used to doing, such as updating Facebook, while at work.

Having an unmonitored channel over which company information is flowing is a real problem, he said, given the increasing need to gather data to satisfy industry regulations; the scrutiny of bodies such as the Information Commissioner and the potential damage a brand would suffer in the wake of a leak.

Even worse, he said, a crackdown on web use during work hours might dissolve the bond of trust that should exist between a worker and their employer.

That relationship would suffer, said Mr Koo, if firms use technology in an adversarial manner.

Far better, he said, was to show employees why security matters to their personal lives as well as in the workplace.

“Remind them that security is about looking after their interests as well as those of the company,” he said.

“A lot of users and employees are not aware of the implications of their day-to-day actions,” he said.

Showing how unprotected phones, laptops or desktops could lead to lost data would help them at home and at work, he said.

“The whole objective here is to build trust,” he said. “You need to get those employees to buy into the reasons you are doing this.”

More trust, he said, meant a workforce that was less likely to leak or feel motivated to expose internal secrets.

USB stick and CD, BBCGood habits can help keep data safe at home and at work

One radical way to avoid the risk of having secrets exposed is to have no internal secrets.

Indian technology firm HCL took this approach as part of a re-working of the company that began in 2005.

The need for change was driven by the realisation that although the company was still growing, the market for outsourcing was growing faster and it was getting left behind.

At the heart of the change, said HCL director Bindi Bullar, was the decision to put employees, rather than their managers, in charge of the business.

“Those that understand the business the best are the employees,” he said. “The value for the company is created between employees and customers.”

Managers at HCL now work to ensure that employees get the support they need to do their job better. Part of that, said Mr Bullar, involved sharing information about how the company is organised, details of employee reviews, who gets paid what and details of contracts and customer contacts.

“Internally we share a lot of sensitive data,” he said, adding that the approach has not been without its problems.

But, he added, sharing that information, sent a strong signal about how much the company trusted its employees and helps to get them more engaged.

“If someone is engaged then you are going to lower the risk of someone blowing the whistle,” he said. “Trust and transparency insulate you from issues like leaks.”

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Obama warns over budget stalemate

John BoehnerHouse Speaker John Boehner met Mr Obama at the White House on Tuesday
Related Stories

Congressional leaders and President Obama failed to reach a budget agreement in talks at the White House, House Speaker John Boehner says.

Mr Boehner was called to the White House for talks on a deal aimed at avoiding a government shutdown.

Talks have stalled over legislation that would mix spending cuts with the funds required to run US federal agencies to the end of September.

Democrats have accused Republicans of linking social policies to the bill.

Mr Boehner and Mr Obama were attempting to resolve a plan that has the potential to cut $33bn (£20bn) from this year’s spending levels and ensure the government does not shut down when a temporary funding measure expires at midnight on Friday.

Following the meeting, Mr Boehner warned that Republicans would not be forced into accepting options they did not wish to endorse.

Mr Boehner said he told President Obama that House Republicans were preparing a week-long stop-gap bill aimed at preventing a shutdown, which includes $12bn (£7.3bn) in immediate spending cuts and enough funds to keep the Pentagon running to the end of September.

Separately, Republicans in the House unveiled longer-term plans to slash the budget deficit by more than $5tn (£3tn) over the next 10 years – combining spending cuts with a restructuring of taxpayer-financed health care for the elderly and the poor.

Mr Boehner said he disputed White House assertions that Democrats and Republicans had agreed to set cuts in spending at $33bn. Republicans want $61bn in cuts.

Republicans on Monday unveiled plans on instructing lawmakers on how the Republican-controlled House would operate if Democrats in the Senate shut down the government.

The White House also advised government agencies on Monday to prepare for a shutdown.

The BBC’s Katie Connolly, in Washington, says that although there hasn’t been a US government shutdown since 1995, the US government shut down 10 times during the Carter and Reagan administrations.

Shutdowns happen because a law passed in 1870 prohibits the government from operating if a budget hasn’t been passed, except in the case of emergencies.

But that law has been interpreted to exempt so-called essential services, including national security, air traffic control, inpatient medical services, emergency outpatient medicine, disaster assistance, prisons, borrowing and taxation, and electricity production, our correspondent adds.

‘Driving federal debt’

Earlier, House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan, a Republican from Wisconsin, released a longer-term plan to slash the budget deficit by about $5 trillion over the coming decade.

In a Wall Street Journal article published on Tuesday, Mr Ryan said Republicans would propose cutting $6.2tn in spending from Mr Obama’s budget over the next 10 years.

Mr Ryan has said Republicans are not “looking for a government shutdown” but are quite serious about demanding cuts in spending to curb federal deficits.

He has also said that lawmakers must find a way to come to deal with a lack of funds going into Medicaid and Medicare, two government programmes he has said are driving the federal debt.

Mr Ryan’s plan includes a proposal to convert Medicare programme into a system by which private insurers would operate plans approved by the federal government.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Asian economic recovery ‘solid’

Containers being loaded into delivery trucks.Surging exports have powered growth in major Asian economies in the past few years

Asia’s developing economies are expected to grow by just under 8% in 2011, according to the Asian Development Bank (ADB).

In its annual Asian Development Outlook it predicted that the region would expand solidly over the next two years.

However, growth rates would be slower than in 2010, it said.

And it warned that inflation would pose a challenge for many Asian countries and could lead to social tensions.

The ADB also said that stronger economic links between developing countries could offset reduced demand for goods and services from recession-hit richer countries.

“Developing Asia, having shown resilience throughout the global recession, is now consolidating its recovery and rapid expansion in the region’s two giants – the People’s Republic of China and India – will continue to lift regional and global growth,” said Changyong Rhee, the ADB’s chief economist.

Asia, excluding Japan, would grow by 7.8% in 2011 and 7.7% in 2012, down from 9% in 2010 when the region rebounded strongly from the global financial crisis, ADB predicted.

“Developing Asia is home to two-thirds of the world’s poor and it is they who are most vulnerable to the effects of price increases”

Changyong Rhee Asia Development Bank

China and India would continue to drive the global and regional economic recovery, it said.

But, like the rest of the region, the two countries would see slower rates of growth than last year, it said.

Economic growth in China was expected to moderate to 9.6% from 10.3% in 2010 as tighter monetary policy takes effect and as demand for exports in major markets such as the US and Europe remained sluggish.

India’s economy was expected to expand by 8.2% in the year to March 2012, down from an expected 8.6% in the year to March 2011.

Mr Rhee said that inflation would be a headache for policy makers in the region as geopolitical tensions in the Middle East and the nuclear crisis in Japan had raised expectations of higher oil prices.

The report said that countries could not rely on tighter monetary policy alone to tackle inflation, but might also have to consider more flexible exchange rates.

Inflation in the 45 Asian economies covered by the report was forecast to rise to 5.3% in 2011, from 4.4% in 2010.

“Developing Asia is home to two-thirds of the world’s poor and it is they who are most vulnerable to the effects of price increases,” said Mr Rhee.

The report also warned that inflation, especially if driven by food prices, could exacerbate inequality and lead to social tensions.

With Europe, the US and Japan still struggling to recover from the effects of the global financial crisis, the ADB said the region would need to look to other developing countries to foster economic growth.

“Growing South-South relations at a time of modest growth in industrial economies could be a potential new driver of global growth,” said Mr Rhee.

“But only if these economies become more open to trade and capital flows with each other.”

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Census ‘dawdlers’ face house call

CensusRepeated failure to fill in the census form could result in a fine of up to £1,000
Related Stories

Seven million households which have not completed and returned the census in England and Wales are being warned that they face a visit from officials.

Some 29,000 census collectors will begin visiting householders who have not returned their questionnaire to help, or persuade, them to complete it.

Completing the census is compulsory and not doing so could mean a £1,000 fine.

Every UK home was sent a survey, which aims to get a snapshot of how people live their lives.

About 26m households in England and Wales were sent the questionnaire.

Those who received the forms had to fill them out on 27 March or as soon as possible afterwards.

The Office for National Statistics (ONS) said legal action will only be taken against people who persistently refuse to complete a questionnaire.

Nearly three-quarters of households have completed and returned the forms.

‘Challenging area’

The north east of England has seen 75% compliance, compared to London which has the lowest compliance rate at just 60%.

The ONS said it had anticipated that London would be a “challenging area” and almost 6,000 collectors would be door-knocking across the city.

Glen Watson, 2011 Census director, said he was “pleased that nearly three-quarters of the forms have come back just nine days after Census Day”.

He said collectors would start visiting households from 1400 BST on Wednesday to collect questionnaires.

The ONS said all 2011 Census field staff will be wearing photo identification badges and carrying other “visibly branded” items.

Anyone unsure about the identity of anyone claiming to be from the census should ask to see their proof of identity before answering any questions.

Those who are still concerned can contact the census helpline on 0300 0201101 in England or the Welsh helpline on 0300 0201130.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Councils ‘use bailiffs for debts’

A parking ticketBailiffs are sometimes used by councils to collect parking fines, campaigners say
Related Stories

Bailiffs are used to collect unpaid council taxes and parking fines in more than two million cases a year, a civil liberties campaign group has said.

Survey figures released to Big Brother Watch, under the Freedom of Information Act, suggest nearly 5,500 cases a day are sent to debt agencies by councils in England, Scotland and Wales.

Campaigners fear bailiffs harass those with debts and charge excessive fees.

The government said it would “rein in the aggressive use of bailiffs”.

Local government and housing minister Grant Shapps said ministers would “defend people’s rights and liberties against home invasion”.

“In addition, we will not be introducing the last government’s plans to allow bailiffs to force entry into homes to collect civil debts,” he said.

It comes after Daniel Hamilton, director of Big Brother Watch, urged the coalition government to act immediately “to end the culture of bully-boy debt collection which has taken hold in town halls across the country”.

“There is nothing trivial about collecting money which funds the vital front line services residents need”

David Sparks, Local Government Association

“Sending in bailiffs to recover debts should always be the absolute last resort,” he said.

It emerged that between 2007/08 and 2009/10, the 320 local authorities who responded to the survey passed 4,527,917 cases to third-party debt recovery agencies for the non-payment of council tax.

And some 1,411,086 cases were passed on for the non-payment of fines for parking infringements.

Two Scottish councils – City of Edinburgh and Glasgow City Council – topped the list of those that used bailiffs most frequently.

Both called in debt recovery agents more than 280,000 times between 2007/08 and 2009/10 – more than 250 cases every day.

David Sparks, vice-chairman of the Local Government Association, said about £530m of council tax went unpaid each year, adding that councils “have a duty to the vast majority of residents who pay their taxes to pursue the small number of individuals who don’t”.

Stressing that calling on bailiffs is “very much a last resort”, he said: “There is nothing trivial about collecting money which funds the vital front line services residents need and want.”

Mr Sparks said people struggling to pay bills are given as much leeway as possible and councils make contact with them a number of times before starting legal proceedings.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.