Mysterious island

Thomas the Tank Engine (c 2011 Gullane (Thomas) LLC. A HIT Entertainment company)Thomas the Tank Engine harks back to the age of steam

Thomas the Tank Engine creator WV Awdry, born 100 years ago, set his railway engine stories in a sort of British Atlantis called Sodor. But where is it?

In Sodor they are celebrating, according to the latest book in the Railway Series of stories started by the Reverend Wilbert (WV) Awdry in 1945.

In the book written by WV Awdry’s son Christopher and marking the centenary of his birth, the engines – after the usual crop of mishaps – transport a bust of their creator to the main station of Sodor where the Fat Controller supervises its unveiling.

But how do you get to Sodor, home of Thomas the Tank Engine and the other locomotives, the Fat Controller and the Troublesome Trucks?

According to WV Awdry, who died in 1997, it’s easy. The Jubilee Bridge at Barrow in Furness actually goes there, he and his brother George wrote in their 1987 book The Island of Sodor. However, ordinary maps say it goes only to Walney Island.

So when you have crossed the bridge, instead of Vickerstown on Walney, you are in “Vicarstown” – gateway to Sodor.

Map of Sodor as imagined by WV Awdry

But Awdry himself admitted that Sodor was an afterthought.

In 1950, he writes in The Island of Sodor, after his first four Railway Series books had been written, that he was poring over maps to “find a suitable location for the Fat Controller’s Railway and map it… standardise the scenery at any given spot, and so avoid troublesome questions”.

A preaching engagement on the Isle of Man made him aware that its bishop is officially Bishop of Sodor and Man – Sodor being an old name for the Hebrides whose ecclesiastical link to Man had long lapsed.

So was born the new Sodor, stretching almost from Furness to Man and described with gentle wit and in enormous detail by the Awdrys in their 1987 book.

But to go there, you need not cross the bridge at Barrow and hope that it will miraculously materialise like a British Atlantis. All over Britain, you find parts of Sodor.

The Talyllyn Railway

The narrow-gauge former slate railway running inland from Tywyn in mid-Wales was the world’s first preserved line, its society being formed in 1951. WV Awdry was one of its earliest members.

WV Awdry, his son Christopher and grandson RichardWV Awdry, his son Christopher and grandson Richard on the Talyllyn Railway, 1982

“He came and volunteered for the first time in ’52. He and his family had a fortnight’s holiday in Tywyn and he worked as a guard,” says David Mitchell, the line’s former managing director.

“And that of course was the famous occasion when they left the tea lady behind, which got written into one of the stories.

“He used to come and oil fishplates and work on the track and things like that in his younger days. And when he died he left us the contents of his study which we have recreated here.”

The Talyllyn Railway and its engines are the basis for the Skarloey narrow-gauge railway in WV Awdry’s books – the first ever railway in Sodor.

Ravenglass and Eskdale Railway

Engines on the Ravenglass and Eskdale RailwaySodor scene? Small engines on the Ravenglass and Eskdale Railway

The scenic narrow-gauge line which carries visitors in open carriages from the Cumbrian coast to the slopes of Scafell Pike inspired the Arlesdale Railway in the Awdry series.

WV Awdry’s first book on the line, Small Railway Engines, includes a visit by the Thin Clergyman (himself) and the Fat Clergyman (his friend the Rev Teddy Boston, who had a railway running round the grounds of his Leicestershire rectory).

Three of the Arlesdale engines – Rex, Bert and Mike – are named after the Ravenglass and Eskdale engines River Esk, River Irt and River Mite.

“It is not difficult to this day to still identify most pages with various sites on the line,” says the railway’s general manager, Trevor Stockton.

A second book in the series, written by Christopher Awdry, is about Jock the New Engine – based on the line’s fourth locomotive, Northern Rock.

The Brighton connection

Awdry says in The Island of Sodor that his best-known creation, Thomas, is a class E2 0-6-0 tank engine from the London, Brighton and South Coast Railway; the Fat Controller acquired him as a result of some nifty accounting following World War I.

Thomas and the E2 class tank engine he is based onThomas (left) from a stamp marking WV Awdry’s centenary, and the E2 engine on which he is based.

Very few of the E2 class were built, and even fewer have the forward extension to the side water tanks which Thomas has.

Thomas first appeared in the second Railway Series book in 1946, in which he is employed moving the carriages for the trains at a big station.

That station with its double arched roof looks quite like Brighton, which would make sense for an engine from the LB&SCR.

Other definite links

Sodor’s Culdee Fell Railway is a rack railway – so steep that the trains have cogs underneath which catch on a toothed rack running up between the rails for extra grip.

China clay engines Alfred and Judy (the model for Bill and Ben) on the Bodmin and Wenford railwayChina clay engines Alfred and Judy (the model for Bill and Ben) on the Bodmin and Wenford railway

Britain’s only rack railway is the Snowdon Mountain Railway, which was visited by Awdry and his friend Teddy Boston in 1963.

Cornwall’s Bodmin and Wenford Railway is home to Alfred and Judy – the inspiration for Awdry’s china clay engines Bill and Ben.

Both worked at Par docks near St Austell where they shunted china clay wagons to the wharfs.

Other possibles

Awdry loved railways large and small. All lines, bridges, stations and engines contributed to the inspiration of the stories. If you have a memory of a railway scene that reminds you of Sodor, it’s likely that Awdry saw it too.

c 2011 Gullane (Thomas) LLC. A HIT Entertainment companyThomas and the other engines watch Awdry’s bust being unveiled

He grew up at Box in Wiltshire, and is supposed to have got the idea of engines talking (“I CAN do it. I WILL do it….”) from the sound as they puffed up the incline on the Great Western line nearby.

Box is near Bath, one end of the Somerset and Dorset Joint Railway – among the most fondly remembered of Britain’s lost lines. It is tempting to find the letters SO DO R in the railway’s name. But Awdry gives no hint of it, nor do SD&JR enthusuasts claim it.

But then, the rest of us will never know everything the Reverend Mr Awdry knew about Sodor.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Bronze Ron

Ronald Reagan statue in BudapestA statue has already been unveiled in Budapest
Related Stories

A statue of Ronald Reagan will be unveiled near the US embassy in London on Monday. How did this come about?

Once upon a time, 4 July in London was the occasion for a grand party at the American ambassador’s vast residence in Regent’s Park.

“When the US embassy relocates in 2017, will people make a special trip to view the statue?”

The diplomatic corps, leading MPs, titans of industry, and we sparrows of the press would feast on hamburgers, hot dogs and crumbs of gossip on the vast back lawn.

But this is the Age of Austerity. The party is over. This year, the big 4 July event in London will be held in Grosvenor Square just across from the American embassy and it is a private affair not hosted by the US government. A statue of Ronald Reagan, 40th president of the United States, will be unveiled.

Baroness Thatcher, Reagan’s soul-mate in power, is expected to attend. As will 2,000 other paying guests who will listen to remarks by British Foreign Secretary William Hague, former US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, and the current ambassador, Louis Susman.

The creation of the statue – total cost $1m – did not grow out of a public clamour for a fitting memorial to the late president (though Westminster City Council made an exception to its usual rule refusing permission for statues until 10 years have passed since the subject’s death).

Roosevelt statue and sculptor William Reid DickThe statue of FDR in Grosvenor Square was funded by public subscription

The event is part of a year-long series of big occasions to mark the centenary of Reagan’s birth, organised by the Ronald Reagan Presidential Foundation. In the weeks prior to the London unveiling, statues have been unveiled and conferences convened in Cracow, Budapest and Prague.

John Heubusch, executive director of the foundation, says the events are part of fulfilling the mission “to preserve and promote the president’s legacy”.

Now, there is a long tradition of private groups honouring their heroes with public memorials.

Across from the Reagan statue is a presidential predecessor, Dwight Eisenhower. It shows Eisenhower in his general’s uniform – his headquarters during the months preparing for D-Day overlook Grosvenor Square – and it was given by the people of Kansas City, Missouri. Eisenhower was from just over the state line in Kansas.

At the other end of the political spectrum, there is the massive bust of Karl Marx in Highgate Cemetery, erected in 1954 by the Communist Party of Great Britain.

Inevitably, the effort to “preserve and promote” Reagan’s legacy comes with a big injection of political spin. A quotation attributed to Lady Thatcher, “Ronald Reagan won the Cold War without firing a shot,” is etched on to the Reagan statue’s plinth.

Actually, there were plenty of shots fired during the Reagan presidency. It’s just they were fired by proxies out of earshot of Washington and London and so are easy to forget.

The epitaph glosses over the pair’s good fortune in arriving in power just as the rot inherent in the Soviet system had fatally weakened the whole structure of the society. It also helped that the USSR was bogged down in an unwinnable war (with US proxies) in Afghanistan.

Margaret Thatcher and Ronald ReaganMargaret Thatcher made friends with Gorbachev – and Reagan met him five times

And it altogether fails to acknowledge the courage of ordinary men and women in the Eastern Bloc who created mass movements out of thin air that ultimately led to the revolutions of 1989.

You don’t have to be an acolyte, though, to appreciate how remarkable a conjunction in Anglo-American history the Reagan-Thatcher era represented, how much they achieved, and how much their world views continue to shape politics on both sides of the Atlantic a quarter of a century after they left office.

They came to power at approximately the same time and set about facing down the same perceived foreign and domestic enemies. Abroad it was Soviet Communism. At home it was the unions and the welfare state.

On the domestic front, both succeeded in reining in the unions but ultimately failed in the larger goal. The welfare state in America and Britain remains in place and politicians tamper with it at their peril – as Prime Minister David Cameron and the Republican Congress are finding out.

But in dealing with the Soviet Union the pair worked like a well-oiled team.

Karl Marx statue in Highgate CemeteryWeird artefact: Plenty of tourists make the trek to Marx’s grave in Highgate

It was Thatcher who first noted that Mikhail Gorbachev was a man with whom the West could do business. Her certification of the Soviet leader’s bona fides led to face-to-face meetings between Reagan and Gorbachev five times – an unprecedented figure between American and Soviet leaders – and genuine negotiations on Strategic Arms Limitation and human rights.

At the same time, for their domestic audiences, Reagan and Thatcher maintained a stance of implacable anti-Communism.

There are enough grey areas in the historical record – not to mention events hidden behind official secrecy rules – to keep historians arguing for centuries about how precisely the Cold War was won.

The Soviet Union is thankfully dead, but people still make the trek to Highgate Cemetery, slightly north of the usual tourist path, to look at Marx’s enormous glowering head. It is a weird artefact of a different time in history.

Grosvenor Square will also find itself off the beaten track in 2017 when the American Embassy relocates south of the river Thames. The Reagan statue will remain. Will people make a special trip to view it?

It seems likely that, in the matter of posthumous memorials, Reagan and Marxism will be going head to head for decades yet.

Michael Goldfarb is a former London bureau chief for National Public Radio, and the author of Emancipation: How Liberating Europe’s Jews from the Ghetto Led to Revolution and Renaissance.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Man charged over JCB damage spree

Cemetery damage at Church WarsopSteven Regan is accused of criminal damage to gravestones in the Church Warsop cemetery

A man has been charged with a string of offences after a JCB was driven through a Nottinghamshire village, leaving a trail of destruction.

Steven Regan, of Leeds, was held after the vehicle was driven through Church Warsop, near Mansfield, on Saturday.

Other vehicles and headstones in a cemetery were damaged in the rampage.

Mr Regan, 34, is accused of the theft of the JCB, various driving offences and criminal damage. He is due before Mansfield Magistrates’ Court on Monday.

The motoring offences he is charged with are dangerous driving, having no insurance and no licence.

The JCB is alleged to have been stolen from Barratt Homes on Sandilands Way in Forest Town, Mansfield.

The police helicopter was deployed during the pursuit of the vehicle, which finally came to a stop after puncturing a tyre.

Mr Regan, of Colenso Terrace, also faces three charges of criminal damage in relation to the headstones and a count of burglary after a JCB was taken from a unit in Leeds in June.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Turkey recognises Libyan rebels

Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu, Benghazi (3 July 2011)Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu: “I am here to express solidarity with the Libyan people”

Turkey has recognised the rebel Transitional National Council as the true representative of Libya’s people.

Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu said it was time for the Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi to go.

Turkey has pledged a further $200m in aid for the rebels in addition to $100m announced last month.

In another development, the rebels have rejected an initiative by the African Union to sponsor talks between them and the government in Tripoli.

Rebel spokesman Abdel Hafiz Ghoga said: “We have rejected it. It did not include the departure of Gaddafi, his sons and his inner circle.”

But TNC head Mustafa Abdul Jalil has conceded that Col Gaddafi is welcome to live out his retirement inside Libya as long as he gives up all power.

“As a peaceful solution, we offered that he can resign and order his soldiers to withdraw from their barracks and positions, and then he can decide either to stay in Libya or abroad,” he told Reuters news agency.

“If he desires to stay in Libya, we will determine the place and it will be under international supervision. And there will be international supervision of all his movements.”

Turkey’s foreign minister met Mr Jalil in Benghazi, the rebels’ main stronghold in eastern Libya, before addressing a news conference in the city.

“Public demand for reforms should be answered, Gaddafi should go and Libya shouldn’t be divided,” said Mr Davutoglu.

“I am here to express solidarity with the Libyan people. Their legitimate right should be realised, there should be a permanent solution to the crisis, which is possible only through a political solution based on the demands of the Libyan people.

“We see the Transitional National Council as the legitimate representative of the Libyan people to achieve their goals.”

Correspondents say Mr Davutoglu’s trip to Benghazi signals that Turkey – a key regional power and Nato member which initially opposed Western-led military action in support of the Libyan rebels – is throwing its weight behind the Libyan opposition.

Turkish companies were involved in construction projects worth billions of dollars in Libya before the outbreak of the anti-government uprising in February.

Meanwhile, the Russian government has said the Libyan crisis will be a key item on the agenda at discussions with Nato on Monday.

The talks, in the southern Russian resort town of Sochi, will include a meeting between Russian President Dmitry Medvedev and Nato Secretary General Anders Fogh Rasmussen.

Russia is a critic of the Nato military action in Libya.

South African President Jacob Zuma will also attend the meeting.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Beyonce conquers UK album chart

Beyonce performs at GlastonburyBeyonce headlined Glastonbury’s main stage last Sunday night
Related Stories

US star Beyonce has claimed pole position in the UK album chart with her new record 4.

The singer, who displaced Lady Gaga from number one, saw previous albums return to the chart in the wake of her performance at Glastonbury last Sunday.

I Am Sasha Fierce, Dangerously In Love and No 1s by Destiny’s Child all marched back into the Top 50.

Beyonce’s single Best Thing I Never Had entered at three, although Jason Derulo held onto the top spot.

Colplay, who took to Glastonbury’s main stage on Saturday night, saw their 2002 single In My Place creep back into the top 40.

And most recent single Every Tear Drop Is A Waterfall, which clambered back to number 10 from last week’s 42.

Their previous album releases also surged into the top 50 on the back of their festival performance, according to the Official Charts Company.

Radio 1 Official Chart show logo

See the UK Top 40 singles chart See the UK Top 40 albums chart BBC Radio 1’s Official Chart Show

Other acts who benefitted from the “Glastonbury effect” in the week following the festival were Plan B, Noah and the Whale and Mumford and Sons.

U2, who played there for the first time in their career, saw their singles collection U218 rise up the ranks to number 61.

Beyonce has scored the second UK chart-topping album of her career with 4. Her solo debut, Dangerously In Love, hit the pinnacle in 2003.

She also had a 2001 number one album with Destiny’s Child and performed a number of their hit singles during her Glastonbury set.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Belarus pledges to defeat ‘plots’

Belarussian President Alexander Lukashenko delivers a speech as he takes part in celebrations marking Independence Day in Minsk, 3 July 2011Mr Lukashenko said he would not allow his government to be overthrown
Related Stories

Belarus President Alexander Lukashenko says recent protests against his rule are an attempt to foment revolution in the former Soviet republic.

Speaking at a military parade in Minsk, President Lukashenko said their goal was to reduce Belarus’s independence “to zero” and bring it “to its knees.”

His speech came after weeks of unprecedented protests.

Activists say an opposition group’s page on a Russian social media site has been blocked to stop further protests.

Mr Lukashenko was addressing a large crowd during independence day celebrations marking the end of Nazi occupation in 1944.

He said he viewed public protests as part of a plot to overthrow him.

“(Somebody) is trying to copy a ‘coloured revolution’ scenario here,” he said, referring to protest movements in ex-Soviet republics such as Georgia and Ukraine in 2003-2004.

“We understand that the goal of these attacks is to impose uncertainty and turbulence, to destroy public consent and in the end to put us on our knees and to bring all the achievements of our independence down to zero. This is not going to happen.”

Protests are rare in Belarus where the authoritarian rule of Mr Lukashenko has led to sanctions by Western governments.

“These are clearly illegal actions undertaken to prevent the protest actions called for on the internet”

Stanislav Shushkevich Opposition member

Demonstrators had been urged to attend the celebrations and start clapping as soon as Mr Lukashenko began his speech.

At least one person who began clapping was quickly led away by plain-clothes police, Reuters news agency reported.

The opposition has held a series of internet-organised marches known as “Revolution by Social Networks”, in which protesters do not carry signs but instead walk through the streets clapping in unison.

The group’s main page on a Russian social media site was blocked on Sunday, with activists saying it was a deliberate attempt to stifle their efforts.

“The authorities are making a titanic effort to break the wave of civil protests,” wrote opposition website Charter 97.

Valentin Stefanovich, from rights group Vesna, said the government had detained dozens of activists while others had been called in by the security forces and warned not to protest.

A column of Belarus army tanks join the rehearsal for the Independence Day military parade in Minsk, Belarus, Thursday, June 30, 2011The day was also marked by a military parade in the capital

Those arrested included Stanislav Shushkevich, the first post-Soviet leader of Belarus and a strong opposition supporter, but he was later released.

“These are clearly illegal actions undertaken to prevent the protest actions called for on the internet,” Mr Shushkevich told AFP news agency.

Last month, about 1,000 people gathered in Minsk to take part in a “silent protest” over the economic crisis organised via social networking sites.

In December 2010, authorities cracked down on protests against alleged vote-rigging in the general election.

International monitors said the contest, in which Mr Lukashenko officially won 80% of the vote, was deeply flawed.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Sit-in protest at closure church

All Saints Church, MaerdyThe church costs £1,000 per month to keep open, says the Church in Wales, on top of needed repairs
Related Stories

Parishioners at a church in Rhondda Cynon Taf are staging a sit-in in protest at its closure.

The final service was held at All Saints in Maerdy on Sunday.

The protesters said they plan to stay for for three days and nights to try to persuade the authorities to grant a year’s grace.

The Church in Wales said All Saints, which opened in 1885, needs £250,000 of repairs and must be sold, with services moved to a community centre.

RCT councillor Gerwyn Evans, an All Saints parishioner who is taking part in the protest, said he thought the building was “too good to lose”.

The protesters had a rota for about half a dozen people to be at the church day and night to hold prayer vigils, he said.

‘Not the only option’

“I think they should have explored every avenue to keep the church open and I don’t think they have.”

Gerywn Evans Councillor

They would also ring the church bell every hour until 2100 BST each evening to show that the community wanted to keep the church, said Mr Evans.

“We feel that we haven’t had the ability to put our views across. There’s a wide group of people in Maerdy who say they want the church.

“We believe it has still got a future in Maerdy. The church was full this morning.

“I just feel that closure was not the only option. I think they should have explored every avenue to keep the church open and I don’t think they have.”

A public meeting last week in support of keeping the church open attracted up to 100 people.

‘Matter of practicality’

“It wasn’t a decision that was taken lightly – it had been discussed many times over the years by the congregation but no alternative to closure was found in tim”

Archbishop Barry Morgan

Barbara Daniel, People’s Warden of the Benefice of Rhondda Fach Isaf, said the congregation was not consulted about moving services to the community centre.

She said: “I know the community centre is a fine building and everything, but it’s not a church.

“We don’t mind going in to the community centre if they will allow us to do work on the church.”

“It’s such a beautiful church. It’s a real shame it has come to this.”

The Archbishop of Wales, Dr Barry Morgan, has previously said the closure has been long-discussed and no alternative has been found.

He said: “It wasn’t a decision that was taken lightly – it had been discussed many times over the years by the congregation but no alternative to closure was found in time.

“it is simply a matter of practicality and pooling our resources together to ensure that a worshipping community can continue in Maerdy.

“I think, therefore, it was the right decision to make.”

The Church in Wales said the building would be put up for sale once the closure was complete.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Syria ‘deploys military in Hama’

YouTube image said to be of mass protest in Hama on 1 JulyOn Friday Hama saw some of the biggest demonstrations yet against President Assad

Syrian troops are being deployed at the restive city of Hama after mass anti-government protests and the sacking of its governor, activists have said.

Troops were taking positions at key entrances to the city, the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said.

On Friday the city saw some of the biggest demonstrations yet against the rule of President Bashar al-Assad.

A day later, Mr Assad sacked the governor of Hama, Ahmad Khaled Abdel Aziz.

Activists say more than 1,350 civilians and 350 security personnel have been killed since protests began in mid-March.

Rami Abdel-Rahman, president of the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, said troops took up positions at Hama late on Saturday and “heavy gunfire” was heard in the city overnight.

He told Reuters news agency there had been a number of arrests on the outskirts of the city.

Map

“The authorities seem to have opted for a military solution to subdue the city,” he said.

One resident also told Reuters that shots had been fired. He said that communications in the city had been cut and that a number of arrests had been made in its Sabounia district.

Tens of thousands of people were said to have taken part in protests in Hama on Friday.

Correspondents say there were reports the army had eased its presence in the city earlier in the week.

Hama was the scene of a Muslim Brotherhood uprising against Mr Assad’s father, Hafez, in 1982, which the army crushed, killing at least 10,000 people.

Mr Rahman also told Agence France-Presse that troops and tanks had deployed to the north-western village of Kfar Rumma.

The Syrian government has not commented on its latest military movements.

Mr Assad has previously accused a “small faction” of “saboteurs” of exploiting popular grievances.

Reports cannot be independently verified as the Syrian authorities have banned most foreign media from the country.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

No 10 warned on benefits cap plan

Communities' Secretary Eric PicklesThe letter was sent from the office of Communities Secretary Eric Pickles
Related Stories

A government department warned that a key Tory policy on welfare reform could result in 20,000 people being made homeless in the UK, it has emerged.

A letter from the communities secretary’s office also warned the PM a benefits cap for unemployed families was likely to cost more than it saved.

It was written by Eric Pickles’ private secretary and leaked to the Observer.

A government source said it would not get into a “running commentary” on the plan and the letter was six months old.

BBC political correspondent Gary O’Donoghue said Conservative sources had stressed that the two-page memo was old. He said this was not a “current row”.

The letter was not written by Mr Pickles himself and he was “fully behind” the policy, his spokesman said.

The memo was written by Nico Heslop, Mr Pickles’ private secretary, and sent to Mr Cameron’s private secretary, Matthew Style.

The letter said the department supported the principle of the benefits cap “on the grounds of fairness” because it was “not right that a household on benefit should receive more than the average working household”.

Analysis

The fact that this document is six months old gives the government significant protection when charges of splits over the policy are levelled.

Sources say that Eric Pickles is completely behind the policy and supports the way it’s being implemented. The difficulty is that senior civil servants don’t go freelancing on policy, particularly when setting out the department’s view to Downing Street.

Indeed, the note itself explicitly suggests Mr Pickles was planning to raise these issues in a meeting on council tax benefit. The sources insist he never raised the issues in cabinet or in any cabinet committee.

So it seems we’re left with a document setting out major worries about the policy and a secretary of state who’s completely relaxed about it.

A couple of possibilities spring to mind: first that Mr Pickles is completely at odds with his private secretary over the matter; or second, and more likely, that he’s been argued round over the course of six months.

But it said the cap could cause some “very serious practical issues”.

It said the policy could result in 20,000 people being made homeless across the UK.

This figure was “on top of the 20,000 additional acceptances already anticipated as a result of other changes to housing benefit”, it said.

It outlined concerns an estimated £270m in savings from the measure did not take into account the financial implications of the policy for local authorities who would have to help more families into housing.

It said the policy “could generate a net cost.”

The letter said the department was worried about the impact of the policy on its ability to build social housing for families.

“To fund new affordable housing development providers need to be able to charge rents of up to 80% of the market levels but the impact of the overall benefit cap will prevent them from doing so in many areas greatly reducing their financial capacity,” it said.

“Initial analysis suggests that of the 56,000 new affordable rent units up to 23,000 could be lost.”

The cap would have the effect of “disproportionately impacting on families and therefore children”, the letter said, because reductions would affect family homes rather than flats.

The letter said removing child benefit from the overall benefits cap could “substantially reduce the negative impacts”.

“This would also mean the overall message of the cap would not be lost,” it added.

Such a move would also reduce the knock-on effect to local authorities and the number of new affordable rent properties lost, the letter said.

Plans for a maximum limit on the amount of benefits one family can claim were announced at the Conservative conference last October.

Chancellor George Osborne said the cap would be set at the amount “the average family gets for going out to work”, which is about £26,000 a year.

The cap would apply to the combined income from benefits including payments such as jobseekers allowance, housing benefit and council tax benefit.

About 50,000 families were expected to be affected by the cap, planned for 2013, and were likely to lose an average of £93 a week.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.