Growing Syrian exodus to Turkey

Refugees walk behind the fence of a refugee camp in the Turkish town of Yayladagi in Hatay province, close to the Syrian border, on Thursday Turkish border guards have been ordered to allow Syrians in

Growing numbers of Syrians are escaping over the border into Turkey ahead of a feared government assault on the northern town of Jisr al-Shughour.

About 1,000 Syrians crossed the border overnight, a Turkish official said, bringing the total number of refugees in Turkey to about 1,600.

Pope Benedict XVI and the UN have urged Syria not to attack its own people.

It comes after the UK and France proposed a UN resolution condemning Syria’s suppression of protests.

The draft stops short of authorising concrete action, but even so it is not clear when or if it might be put to a vote, correspondents say.

Russia and China have now said they strongly oppose the draft resolution, with Moscow saying Syria must settle its internal conflict without any foreign interference.

“The situation in this country, in our opinion, does not pose a threat to international peace and security,” a Russian foreign ministry spokesman is quoted as saying by Russian state media.

The anticipated crackdown on Jisr al-Shughour is in response to claims by Damascus that armed gangs killed 120 members of the security forces there.

It says local residents have requested the army’s intervention to restore peace and quiet.

But dissenting accounts say the violence was sparked by deserting soldiers, and that loyal troops have massacred peaceful civilians.

At the scene

Local Turkish officials seem unsure how to handle the influx. Police are preventing journalists from talking to the refugees, many of whom are being housed in a fenced and tightly guarded Red Crescent camp in the town of Yayladagi.

In the Turkish village of Guvecci, less than a kilometre from the border, trucks have been moving along the road that runs inside Turkey along the border to pick up people who had just got out of Syria. The same road occasionally has Turkish ambulances taking injured refugees for medical attention in Turkey

Local Turkish residents, many of them relatives of the Syrians, know when and where people are trying to cross the border because they are able to communicate by mobile phones fitted with Turkish SIM cards.

The Syrian authorities have disrupted local mobile phone networks.

Syrian refugees fear a massacre

Human rights groups say more than 1,000 people have been killed since protests began in February against the rule of President Bashar al-Assad, and it now appears several hundred security forces may also have died.

The BBC’s Owen Bennett-Jones, who is in Guvecci on the Turkish side of the border with Syria, said on Thursday morning that trucks were arriving and disgorging passengers on the Syrian side every 10 or 15 minutes.

Some passengers were quickly seizing the chance to slip into Turkey under the eye of Turkish border guards who have been ordered by Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan to allow them in.

Other Syrians, our correspondent says, are hiding out in fields and orchards, waiting to see how ferocious the army campaign will be before deciding whether to move on to Turkey.

A Turkish official who spoke anonymously says the influx of Syrians is sharply increasing, and the latest arrivals have included several dozen wounded in security crackdowns.

Many are sheltering in a tent city run by the Red Crescent in the town of Yayladagi, with plans to set up a second camp in Altinozu.

Map

Most of the refugees were too frightened to speak to our correspondent.

But one man, who spoke on condition his identity be concealed, said he had made a three-hour trek from Jisr al-Shughour, dodging Syrian soldiers along the way.

“The circumstances there are very difficult,” the man told our correspondent. “They are planning to invade.”

He said an estimated 30,000 Syrian soldiers were massing in a nearby village – but added that hundreds of soldiers had also deserted and were also gathering on the border hoping to make an escape into Turkey.

Another refugee said 13 or 14 tanks were now surrounding Jisr al-Shughour.

The refugees’ testimony cannot be independently verified but appears to accord with the testimony of others, such as “Youssef”, an unofficial spokesman for the refugees who spoke to the BBC World Service.

Most international journalists have been denied entry into Syria.

Reem Haddad

Reem Haddad said: ”They are fleeing from the armed groups who have massacred 120 people, there is no army in Jisr al-Shughour”

Reem Haddad, a spokeswoman for the Syrian information ministry, confirmed in an interview with the BBC that Syrian troops were gathering around Jisr al-Shughour.

But she said they had been asked by local residents to restore peace and quiet after the violence she blamed on “armed groups”.

She said there was no influx of refugees into Turkey, but just the normal passage of Syrians across to the border to Turkish villages where their relatives lived.

The armed groups had cut off roads leading to Jisr al-Shughour, she added.

“No country in the world allows this to happen to it,” said Ms Haddad. “The government has a presence and it must be felt.”

Syrian refugees waiting to cross over into Turkey, 8 June 2011

The UN human rights chief, Navi Pillay, and the Pope have urged Damascus to show restraint.

Mr Pillay said Syria should halt “its assault on its own people”, saying it was “deplorable for any government to attempt to bludgeon its population into submission”.

Pope said Syria must recognise “the inalienable dignity of all people” if it wished to achieve stability.

The recent protests “show the urgent need for real reforms”, the news agency AFP quoted him as saying.

The draft UN resolution submitted by Britain and France with the support of Germany and Portugal condemns the systematic violation of human rights in Syria. It demands an immediate end to violence, and access for humanitarian workers.

It stresses that the only solution to the crisis is through an inclusive and Syrian-led process, which correspondents say is an attempt to satisfy council members who want to avoid another Libya-style intervention.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Volcano visitors

As Chile’s Puyehue-Cordon Caulle volcano has proved in recent days, these open scars on the Earth’s crust that throw out molten lava, ash and gases can be hazardous and deadly. But painstaking work is going on to try to help us understand how volcanoes behave.

Dr Tamsin Mather from the University of Oxford is part of such a team trying to take the pulse of the planet. She is revealing her research at this year’s Cheltenham Science Festival – and here explains how she is trying to unlock the secrets of the world’s volcanoes.

To see the enhanced content on this page, you need to have JavaScript enabled and Adobe Flash installed.

The Times Cheltenham Science Festival runs between the 7-12 June 2011.

Images subject to copyright – click ‘show captions’ for details. Maps courtesy The Geological Society of America and Bing Maps.

Music courtesy KPM Music. Slideshow production by Paul Kerley. Publication date 9 June 2011.

Related:

Department of Earth Sciences – University of Oxford

The Geological Society of America

The Times Cheltenham Science Festival 2011

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites.

More audio slideshows:

Probing plasma

Beautiful science

Seeing into space

Noctilucent clouds

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Call to cut ‘chemical cosh’ drugs

Elderly womanThere are around 750,000 people living with dementia in the UK
Related Stories

More than 50 health and social care organisations are calling for fresh action to cut the prescription of “chemical cosh” drugs.

Around 180,000 people with dementia are thought to be prescribed antipsychotic drugs in the UK.

But 80% of those prescriptions are said by critics to be inappropriate.

Long-term use of the drugs can make dementia symptoms worse, reduce the ability to talk and walk and increase the risk of stroke and even death.

The Dementia Action Alliance – which includes the Alzheimer’s Society, Age UK and the Department of Health – want all prescriptions for antipsychotics to be reviewed by the end of March 2012.

To help patients and carers, the Alliance has published a booklet giving information and advice about how to make sure antipsychotics are not prescribed inappropriately.

Antipsychotics have a powerful sedative effect and are often used when dementia patients become aggressive, agitated or distressed.

“It is unacceptable that 1,800 people with dementia die prematurely every year as a result of antipsychotic medication”

Paul Burstow MP Care Services Minister

They are most commonly given to dementia sufferers in care homes and hospitals.

Guidelines say they should only be used as a last resort and over a short period of time, but the evidence suggests that in some cases they are being prescribed for years.

A study published in January 2009 showed the medication nearly doubled the risk of death for many dementia patients when taken over a prolonged period.

Jeremy Hughes, Chief Executive of the Alzheimer’s Society, said it was unacceptable that people with dementia were having their health and quality of life put at risk because of antipsychotics:

“It is essential we bring an end to this chemical cosh and empower people with dementia and carers with the information they need to ensure they are not prescribed these drugs inappropriately. This call to action can do just that.

“It’s not just about reducing antipsychotics but also about improving quality care. This means developing alternative treatments and finding better ways to manage pain and other medical conditions.”

Following an independent report for the government in November 2009 that found the drugs killed around 1,800 patients a year, ministers announced plans to cut prescribing rates by two-thirds within three years.

But new figures from the NHS Information Centre suggest prescription may have dropped by less than 20% over the past two years.

When in opposition, Paul Burstow, now Care Services Minister, campaigned to cut the use of the ‘chemical cosh’.

“It is unacceptable that 1,800 people with dementia die prematurely every year as a result of antipsychotic medication. That is why I’m backing this campaign,” he said.

“Reducing the use of antipsychotic medication is one of the Coalition Government’s four key priorities for dementia. With the right support, people can live well with dementia and continue to do the things they enjoy for years after diagnosis.”

The campaign is also being supported by Dr Clare Gerada, Chair of Royal College of General Practitioners.

“Dealing with very agitated or aggressive patients can be distressing, and it can be difficult knowing what to do for the best of the patient, but antipsychotics should in most cases only be used as a last resort, and for the short term.

“Antipsychotics have potential to do real harm to patients, including an increased risk of stroke. There are viable alternatives – including behavioural therapies – that we should encourage wherever possible to ensure the care our patients receive is appropriate, in their best interests and does not cause them harm.”

Rebecca Wood, Chief Executive of Alzheimer’s Research UK, the UK’s leading dementia research charity, said:

“Action to reduce the prescription of these drugs and develop alternative treatments has lacked urgency.

“This campaign should renew that urgency and drive home the need to invest in more research so that safer, more effective treatments can be found.”

Martin Green of the English Community Care Association, a body that represents care homes, said: “ECCA really welcomes the commitment by the Department of Health to reduce anti-psychotic prescribing and we want to see all sections of the system – primary care, acute hospitals, pharmacists and care homes – working in partnership to reduce inappropriate anti-psychotic prescribing”.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Exam question errors under attack

girl taking exam Hundreds of thousands of teenagers are taking public exams
Related Stories

The exams watchdog Ofqual has criticised a series of mistakes on AS-level exam papers and ordered extra checks.

Three exam papers taken by students in England, Wales and Northern Ireland had questions which were incomplete or impossible to answer correctly. Two others are being investigated.

Ofqual said the run of errors was “disappointing and unacceptable”.

The exam bodies said they were carrying out extra checks.

The errors affect tens of thousands of students, many of whom will be relying on the results for their university applications.

Several have contacted the BBC News website to complain.

The head of England’s exams watchdog Ofqual has written to all the exam boards on behalf of the exam regulators in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

Ofqual’s chief executive Glenys Stacey told the exam bodies to carry out extra checks on GCSE and A-level papers being taken this term and to make sure measures are in place to deal with any errors that occur.

“We take instances like this very seriously – I am calling on awarding organisations to take steps now to protect students from further disruption and anxiety”

Glenys Stacey Chief Eexecutive, Ofqual

“While the vast majority of question papers taken so far have been free from error, there have been a number of question papers that have included errors,” she said.

“We take instances like this very seriously. I am calling on awarding organisations to take steps now to protect students from further disruption and anxiety.”

The watchdog says that so far, the number of mistakes reported is similar to other years, but it is stepping in to maintain public confidence.

It is investigating complaints about errors in two other exam papers but has not yet released the details.

The three exam boards involved in the confirmed mistakes say measures are in place which will ensure candidates do not suffer.

The errors on the AS-level papers involved:

A maths question which was impossible to answer because not enough information was given (OCR)A business studies question which did not give enough information (AQA)A multiple-choice biology question which gave several possible answers but not the correct one (Edexcel)

The marks at stake varied from just one out of a total of 425 in the biology exam, to the maths question, which was worth 11% of the total marks on the paper.

AS-levels are qualifications in their own right but are also taken by teenagers as the first stage of their A-levels.

Some of those who messaged the BBC News website said they were worried the mistakes could cost them a place at university.

Natalie Edwards, from Stevenage, told the BBC: “The exam was hard enough without having mistakes on questions that are designed for people to be able to pick up the easier marks. I couldn’t work out why I wasn’t getting any of the answers in the paper, which caused me to get stressed.”

Sarah Streiber, from Wales, said she took both the business and maths papers in which errors appeared, and was hoping to go to university before increased tuition fees are introduced in 2012.

“And now I have potentially lost that chance! Thank you very much to the examiners who have let thousands of us down,” she said.

The exam bodies have released a statement as a group, saying nearly all of the tens of thousands of examination questions published each year are error-free.

They add that extra checks are being carried out.

Director of the Joint Council for Qualifications Jim Sinclair said: “Awarding bodies are aware that a small number of questions in this year’s exam papers have contained errors and understand the distress this may have caused students.

“Students and parents should be assured that no one will be disadvantaged as a result of these mistakes. Examiners marking the papers are aware of the incidents and will make careful adjustments so that all students receive the marks they deserve.”

The exams watchdog Ofqual has powers to name exam bodies which make errors, and to direct them to take certain actions to rectify the situation.

Its ultimate sanction is to withdraw recognition from an awarding body – effectively removing its powers to set and mark public exams.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Murder charge after man, 83, dies

Paul CoxMr Cox’s 84th birthday would have been on Tuesday

A man has been charged with the murder of an 83-year-old man who was found dead at his home in Worcestershire.

Paul Cox was found at his semi-detached home in Waseley Road, Rednal, Worcestershire, on Friday morning.

West Mercia Police said a 22-year-old man from Birmingham who was arrested on Sunday has been charged with the murder of Mr Cox, burgling his house and stealing his car.

The man will appear at Redditch Magistrates’ Court later.

Mr Cox’s 84th birthday would have been on Tuesday.

Another man previously arrested was released on bail on Wednesday.

A third man arrested in connection with Mr Cox’s death was released without charge.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

EMA grants study ‘misinterpreted’

EMA protestersThe scrapping of EMA became part of the wave of student protests during the winter

Ministers “misinterpreted” research they cited to justify axing education grants for low-income English 16-19 year olds, the study’s author has said.

The government axed the Education Maintenance Allowance of up to £30 a week, saying 88% of money spent on it was ineffective or “deadweight cost”.

But Thomas Spielhofer, who led the study on which the claim was based, told MPs this was a misinterpretation.

The government said its decision was not based on just one study.

The £560m EMA scheme provided means-tested grants to help young people stay on at school or college.

Students protested when ministers scrapped the scheme and replaced it with a £180m bursary fund to be allocated mainly by colleges, which it said would be better targeted at the poorest students.

The government has frequently cited Mr Spielhofer’s study, done for the National Foundation for Educational Research, in defence of its decision.

The study questioned 2,029 students, of whom 838 said they received EMA.

When asked whether they would have remained in education or training if they did not receive EMA, 88% of the 838 said “yes”, while 12% said “no”.

Giving evidence to the Education Select Committee, Mr Spielhofer said: “You can interpret that in different ways. You can interpret it quite negatively, and say that for 88% that was wasted money, but I don’t actually see it that way, I think it has been misinterpreted in that sense.”

He said that for some of the 88%, the EMA payments would have “made no difference”, but for others, finance would have been a consideration, and the fact that they would have stayed on showed “resilience”.

Asked whether he was “happy with the concept that EMA has a deadweight cost of 88%”, he said “no”.

He also replied that it was “completely correct” when asked if he was unhappy that the change in government policy had been based on his research.

A spokesman for the Department for Education said the decision to replace the EMA with “a far more cost effective and targeted scheme” was “not made on the back of one survey”.

“There is a range of evidence which shows that the bulk of the money was not getting to those who most needed it and that initial gains in participation had reached a plateau,” the spokesman said.

“We can no longer afford the luxury of paying substantial incentives to young people who would have stayed on anyway.”

The University and College Union said the government had “clearly cherry-picked one statistic from one report in order to justify scrapping an entire system of financial support for young people”.

It said the EMA made a “huge difference in keeping young people in education”.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

UN chief calls for ‘end to Aids’

An Indian woman walks past a poster advertising an Aids-awareness programme in Bangalore (file)In India, the rate of new HIV infections fell by more than 50%, according to UNAids
Related Stories

UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon has called for global action to end the Aids disease by 2020.

“That is our goal – zero new infections, zero stigma and zero Aids-related deaths,” Mr Ban said at a UN summit on Aids in New York.

The three-day meeting marks the 30th anniversary since the discovery of HIV – the virus that leads to Aids.

Meanwhile, African leaders called for greater resources to battle the pandemic across the world.

Some 34m people have Aids, but about half of them do not know they have the disease, according to the UN.

“Today, we gather to end Aids,” Mr Ban said at the opening of the United Nations General Assembly meeting on Wednesday.

“If we are to relegate Aids to the history books we must be bold. That means facing sensitive issues, including men who have sex with men, drug users and the sex trade,” the UN chief said.

30 years of HIV5 June 1981: Center for Disease Control mentions a new virus in its weekly mortality report1982: The term Aids (acquired immunodeficiency syndrome) first used1984: Virus identified and named HIV1985: Rock Hudson dies of Aids, teenage haemophiliac Ryan White expelled from school because infected through treatment1987: First showing of Aids Memorial Quilt on National Mall in Washington DC1991: Jeremy Irons wears red ribbon and basketball’s Magic Johnson has the virus1993: Philadelphia film wins two Oscars2000: Infection rate in US among African Americans overtakes that in gay men2011: Global death toll 22m, infections 60mHow a red ribbon conquered the world ‘More money needed’ for HIV cure

Mr Ban stressed that new infections have dropped by 20% since 2001 – the year when world leaders first pledged to act to control the pandemic.

He also urged the global community to “come together in global solidarity as never before” to achieve universal access to Aids treatment by 2015 and also efforts to lower costs.

The meeting is being attended by 30 presidents and heads of government, and some of the African leaders spoke of the desperate need for more funds to fight the disease.

“To say that adequate funding is critical to the success of our HIV and Aids response is an understatement,” said Nigerian President Goodluck Jonathan, whose country has the highest number of HIV-positive people after South Africa.

Gabon’s President Ali Bongo Ondimba said that resources available for Africa “remain insufficient given the size of the HIV/Aids impact on the continent”.

More than 9m people still do not get retroviral treatment to keep HIV/Aids at bay, and an estimated 1.8m people die each year from Aids.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Peers run up expenses bill of £6m

Lord Hanningfield and Lord TaylorLord Hanningfield and Lord Taylor have both been convicted of expenses fraud
Related Stories

Peers claimed more than £6m of expenses between October and December 2010, according to new figures.

Among those paid were Lord Taylor of Warwick and Lord Hanningfield – both of whom have since been convicted of expenses fraud.

Members of the Lords, who are not paid a salary, can claim an attendance allowance of £300 or £150 a day, plus travel and secretarial costs.

This is the first data published since a new expenses regime was created.

The “clocking in” allowance of £300 – or £150 for those who attend only part of a sitting day – replaced the previous £174-a-night “overnight subsistence” allowance, which was at the centre of most alleged expenses abuses involving the Lords system.

Peers living outside London were entitled to claim the allowance to cover the cost of staying away from their main home while working, yet no definition of a “main home” was supplied in the rules.

According to the newly released figures, 25 peers – out of more than 800 – claimed more than £16,000 in the three-month period.

Labour peer and former minister Lord Sewel claimed the most overall, £23,428, and attended 41 of the 49 days on which the House sat. He also worked away from Westminster on 16 days.

A significant portion of his expenses – more than £8,000 – was for travel from his home in Aberdeenshire to Westminster.

Conservative peer Lord Bates claimed the highest amount for attendance alone – £15,450 – for the full 49 days on which the House sat, plus an additional £750 for days working away from Westminster.

Labour’s Lord Berkeley was the only peer to claim for riding a bicycle, receiving £14.

Former Tory peer Lord Taylor was jailed for 12 months in May after being convicted of falsely claiming £11,277 in parliamentary expenses.

Fellow ex-Tory Lord Hanningfield is currently awaiting sentence after he was found guilty of falsely claiming nearly £14,000.

Last week, it emerged that former Labour MP Eric Illsley was paid thousands of pounds in expenses – after pleading guilty to expenses fraud.

Illsley resigned as an MP the day before he was jailed, and the expenses watchdog Ipsa said that, under the rules, he had been entitled to claim up until that point.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

VIDEO: Gaddafi accused of using rape as weapon

The International Criminal Court’s chief prosecutor says there is evidence that Libyan leader Col Muammar Gaddafi ordered the rape of hundreds of women as a weapon against rebel forces.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Brazil won’t extradite fugitive

Battisti supporters protest outside Brazil's Supreme CourtBattisti’s supporters rallied outside the Supreme Court in Brasilia
Related Stories

Brazil’s Supreme Court says it won’t extradite a former left-wing Italian militant, Cesare Battisti, to Italy.

Italy had appealed against a decision by former Brazilian President Lula da Silva to deny an extradition request.

But the Supreme Court ruled the Italy lacked legal standing to challenge the decision.

Battisti, 56, escaped from an Italian prison, where he was awaiting trial on four murder charges, which he has always denied.

The nine Supreme Court judges voted 6-3 to refuse Italy’s attempt to appeal, and ordered that Battisti should be freed.

“At stake here is national sovereignty. It is as simple as that,” said Judge Luiz Fux, one of the nine.

Cesare Battisti says he is the victim of political persecution in Italy.

He has been on the run since escaping from an Italian jail in 1981 while awaiting trial, and was convicted of murder in absentia in 1990.

He spent many years in France – where he started a career as a novelist – before moving to Mexico and finally Brazil, where he was arrested in 2007.

Last year, the Brazilian government accepted Mr Battisti’s request for political asylum, but the supreme court ruled the designation was illegal as he was convicted of “common crimes” rather than political acts.

Former President Lula’s decision to refuse the Italian extradition request, a day before he left office in January, caused fury in Italy, which withdrew its ambassador.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Chimps re-enact one of Aesop’s fables

Spitting chimp

This chimp takes water from a dispenser and spits it into a tube to reach a peanut

Related Stories

Chimps have “replayed” an ancient fable, a team says in Plos One journal.

In Aesop’s 2,000-year-old tale, a crow uses stones to raise the water level in a pitcher to reach the liquid so as to quench its thirst.

But when given a similar set up, chimps were able to attain an out-of-reach, floating peanut by spitting water taken from a dispenser into a vertical tube.

One hungry chimp went even further by urinating into the vessel to get hold of the prized snack.

“He was spitting water into the tube, then got frustrated”

Daniel Hanus Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Biology

“He was spitting water into the tube, then got frustrated,” explained lead researcher Daniel Hanus from the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Biology in Leipzig, Germany.

“So he started peeing and then he realised: ‘Wait a minute, if I move in that direction, that fills up the tube’.”

The chimp’s unusual method proved successful, the scientist said. The fact that the peanut was urine-sodden did not deter the animal from eating it, he added.

Urinating chimp

This chimp takes a different approach to solve the problem – he urinates into the tube

The study was carried out with gorillas and chimpanzees.

The primates were presented with a vertical glass tube, which was secured to a cage so it could not be moved or broken. At the bottom was a peanut, floating on a small amount of water.

“You cannot explain it by trial-and-error learning”

Daniel Hanus Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Biology

They were also given access to a water dispenser.

The idea was that the animals would take water from the dispenser in their mouths, and then spit it into the tube to raise the water level.

It would take several visits back and forth between the dispenser and tube to gather enough water to get to the peanut.

The team found that none of the five gorillas was able to complete the task.

Chimps however were more successful. Out of 43 chimps, based in the Ngamba Island Chimpanzee Sanctuary, in Uganda, and Germany’s Leipzig Zoo, 14 worked out that they needed to take the water in their mouths and spit it into the tube, and seven did this enough times to successfully obtain a peanut.

Dr Hanus said the study highlighted the chimps’ ability to solve problems.

Chimpanzee (Arup Shah/Naturepl.com)The researchers were impressed that some chimps were able to solve the problem

He explained: “You cannot explain it by trial-and-error learning. They weren’t just spitting water around the room and some fell in by accident.

“Instead, they were standing in front of the problem, trying to work out the solution – at first by trying to use their fingers, or trying to break it.

“But some, then went to the drinker and got the mouthful of water and came back and spat it directly into the tube, and a few did it enough times to get the peanut.”

He added: “I think it is quite impressive – I call it insightful behaviour.”

The urinating chimp, he said, was an interesting case.

The animal had initially solved the problem using the standard spitting technique, but when tested again, he was struggling to direct the water into the tube.

The urine did the trick, said Dr Hanus.

He said: “He seemed like he understood. He was like: ‘That’s cool, this helps me’.”

Child’s play

The team also repeated the study with children of varying ages.

“Even the older children found it hard”

Daniel Hanus Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Biology

Dr Hanus said: “Whenever we talked to people about this task, they’d say: ‘Well, this is a demanding task, it is tricky – I don’t know if I could solve that’.

“So we decided to test four, six and eight-year-olds.”

This time, the subjects were given a watering can to fill up the tube rather than rely on a water dispenser and a refined spitting technique.

The researchers found that the four-year-olds were outperformed by the chimps: only two out 24 younger children could solve the problem.

Six-year-olds did better, with 10 out of the 24 managing to work out they needed to use the water. And eight-years-olds did the best, 14 children – 58% – completed the task.

Dr Hanus said: “Even the older children found it hard. It was interesting and impressive to see how difficult it was for them.”

Rook

Aesop’s rook: The birds raise the water by dropping stones into a tube so they can reach a floating worm

This research follows a similar study carried out with orangutans in 2007. They were very good at solving this problem: five out of the five primates tested could successfully complete the task.

The team said the difference between the three primate species was striking – although they plan to test the gorillas again using a slightly different set-up.

Birds too have been able to carry out this task.

A paper published in 2009 revealed that rooks were highly successful at working out a solution to this problem.

With a slightly experiment design, where the birds had to drop stones into the water, and a peanut exchanged for a floating maggot, the team found that all four of the rooks tested could complete the task.

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

Council apology over data blunder

Salary adviceThe information was given out in response to a request about council salaries
Related Stories

Dumfries and Galloway Council has apologised to about 900 staff after it gave out personal data which was then published on the internet.

The details were given out in error in response to a Freedom of Information request on employee salaries.

Staff names and dates of birth were disclosed and subsequently put onto a website on 23 March.

The council had the information removed as soon as it was told about it by Unison union officers on 1 June.

The FoI request was one of a series made to all local authorities across Scotland about workers on protected pay deals.

DGC admitted it had given out additional worker details in error.

A council statement said: “The council regularly provides salary information in response to inquiries.

“However, in providing this information, some employees’ names and dates of birth were disclosed by mistake.

“Some details of their employment were also supplied, however this is not classed as personal information.”

“As soon as we made them aware of it, within two hours it was off the website – we couldn’t have asked for a quicker response”

Marion Stewart Unison branch secretary

All of the information was then posted on the internet, on a website specialising in highlighting FoI requests, where it was available to view for more than two months.

The situation was pointed out to the trade union Unison which immediately highlighted its concerns to the council.

The authority had the details removed and also contacted the Scottish Information Commissioner’s office about the incident.

The council statement added: “The council has contacted all of the employees affected by this incident and apologised.”

It said steps were being taken to prevent any repeat of the incident.

Unison branch secretary Marion Stewart said the council had been unaware the details were on the website for about 10 weeks.

“They had no idea this had happened until one of our members phoned me,” she said.

“As soon as we made them aware of it, within two hours it was off the website – we couldn’t have asked for a quicker response.”

The union has now advised the staff involved to complain to the council and the information commissioner.

It has also told them to keep a close eye on all bank and credit card accounts for unusual activity due to concerns about data fraud.

Ms Stewart said it was particularly upsetting for the staff involved as they are workers who will see their wages reduced at the end of a three-year protected period.

“We have 900 disgruntled members of staff,” she said.

“As of next year they will have a cut in salary, so they are already feeling undervalued.”

This article is from the BBC News website. © British Broadcasting Corporation, The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.